No he isn't - well I don't know any that don't rate him. Mind you we get to see him a lot. The ones that don't rate him probably don't even go to games (and no that is not pointed at you Alps).
The players that went are now on the whole getting **** from the fans at the clubs they have gone to. Reason for this IMHO is that our midfield flattered them. Samuels and his ilk couldn't spot a whore in a whorehouse. ?