Rebel

So that's our winger/creative midfielder then. I was hoping for Matt Phillips from Blackpool on a permanent, Jonjo Shelvey on loan from Liverpool or Soriano from Barca B on loan when someone said Spanish! . They say he can play in lots of positions so I hope he not our 'other striker' as well. I can't say that I'm wowed by this signing as he's moved around an awful lot for a 21 year old. Suggests he wasn't good enough for Barca and Juve or has an attitude problem of some sort and they both got rid of him because of it. I also thought we were supposed to be building a team for the Premiership - a 21 year old Spanish player on loan doesn't quite fit that bill. An 'Arry Redknapp hand-me-down doesn't feel right either. By the time he's adjusted to English football he will be back at Spurs. Where does this leave us with Puncheon as it doesn't look like he going anywhere is part exchange - or get a place in the team. I think we'll end up selling him to Blackpool for something far short of what we'd hoped for. It also looks like we don't actually have a lot of money to spend - or wont spend it if we do. It will be loans for us I think. Matthew Kilgallon, Sylvan Ebanks-Blake and Adam Hammill on loan anyone?

Blimey - someone just told me its a double whammy - Rory Delap and Danny Higgingbotham!

We're not going to have all that ITK sh*te again are we!? Besides I don't believe we have the money to throw around that some people seem to think we do. If we had I don't think we would have signed Tandanari Lee.

Lets see if he's any good first - or even makes it on to the pitch!

We don't need a deep lying striker - we need a centre forward to lead the line and to play in front of Lambert just like Barnard did last season. Barnard is the closest we have got and I'm not sure we will see him in a Saints shirt again this season until its all but done if at all. Even then he like to go wide and drop deep for the ball. As does Connolly who is too short to lead the line anyway. Both like to play-off a big man as well. Do Prado has the height but is really an attacking midfielder (not a winger either) who is best attacking the box when a centre forward has made the space for him to run in to. And if we're honest Lamberts best position is as a second striker dropping deep to pick up the ball and set up the play or attacking the space behind another striker to score the goals. At the moment we have become very predictable - and a bit one dimensional - with the cross too Lambert at the far post our main route to goal. We're not creating the space in the box for the attacking midfielders/forwards to run in to. I'm just not convinced Tandanari Lee - coming from the J-League - will be the physical presence we need to lead the line. I'm hope I'm wrong. I hope we don't end up regretting Lucas Juktiewitz signing for Middlebrough - and not us come the end of the season. At £2 million he would have made a real difference to us. £2 million for a return of £50 million is good business as well. Players like Sharp and Maynard are probably going to end up in the Premier League at clubs like Norwich or West Brom. Burnley aren't going to sell Jay Rodriguez or Charlie Austin as they don't need the money and are aiming for the play-offs and Gary Hooper won't leave Celtic until the Summer after a treble and that will be for the Premier League (possibly us if we can get there) Juktiewitz was probably the best of the rest - and one of the few that was in our reach.

Celtic and Rangers are massive clubs in Scottish Football terms -and they do get to play in Europe every season - I'll give them that - but normally only for a couple of games. And they do both have big support bases - I'll give them that as well. But 50,000 or 60,000 crowds do look really big when the average club in your league only gets crowds of 15,000. They also have that same 'big club' arrogance as Man Utd and Liverpool supporters - and loads of supporters in Ireland! But I'm not sure they'd thrive in the EPL where there are 6 or so clubs that can regularly pull in crowds of 40,000, 60,000 and even 80,000. Not to mentions the rest - most of whom can easily pull in 30,000 or so each week. In Football terms the SPL is probably on a par with League 1 in England in terms of standard and competition. Lallana, Cork, Lambert, Schneiderlin, Chaplow, Fox and Fonte would all make it into the current Celtic team by quite some way - all have a better pedigree than Hooper and Commons for a start. And right now if we played them over several games we'd win more than we'd lose. The last time we played them it was more or less our youth team - but don't tell them that it will spoil their illusion. It doesn't make us a bigger club in terms of support - but we are one that could be playing in the EPL next season (and that would probably makes us as wealthy if not more so than Celtic) - and if Hooper wants a place in the England squad it may be a bus he wants to catch. I can't see a premier league club outside of the relegation battle taking a gamble on him. By the way I'd welcome Celtic and Rangers into a two tier British Premier League - as long as they left all that sectarian stuff at home.

I thought Ishmael Miller was a shadow of the player he used to be a couple of years ago - and apart from throwing his weight around a bit in the first 10 minutes or so didn't trouble our centrebacks at all as they out fought and out thought him

He's probably injured again. He always seems to be injured. But I would guess he is on his way as well. He's good on the ball but he has no pace or hight and seems to lack the physical robustness a player needs at this level.

9 times at the age of 26 isn't great to be fair - and his league scoring record is no better than players like Rodriguez and Juktiewitz - and nowhere near as good as Maynard and Sharp. I'm not sure the J League is a great standard either - a lot of players still go there for a last pay day. I can't imagine its as high a standard as the Championship to be honest. Also FIFA rankings aren't necessarily a great guide - Japan probably are the best team in Asia - but that's probably carried them up the rankings a bit. I'm not sure they would be so high if they played teams from Europe, South America or Africa more regularly. Don't forget England are highly ranked by FIFA at the moment and I think most of us would agree that's probably more than a bit misleading!

I was sceptical about the Jos Hoovied signing I'll give you that - but then I'm a natural cynic - it seemed a bit last resort at the time from the outside where we all look in from - and our track record with players from Scotland hasn't been great. But I tried to keep and open mind and see what he could do on the pitch. I wasn't totally convinced after his first game where he seemed to head the ball up in the air a lot rather than out of the danger area - but he showed good touches on the ground and an ability to read the game. Second game he seemd to come to terms with the pace and physicality and has been great ever since. But he has turned out to be a great signing. His track record prior to Celtic was great so all in all we seem to have grabbed a bargain with Hoovied. I'll try and keep an open mind with Tandanari but his J League background and scoring record do make it a bit of a gamble - but I'd be happier with more of a proven goal scorer at Championship level. We have a real chance of getting promoted this season - now is the time to do everything we can to make it happen. We may not get another chance as good as this for a while. I'm not sure we're talking about a Messi here to be fair - besides we have our own in Lallana.! And I am sure most fans would agree what we need is a centre forward to lead the line right now! One question - why on this forum when someone expresses an opinion do people always respons with personal attacks, abuse or negative responses? Here's a challnge for you - try coming back with reasoned argument of a constructive response. I truly am hoping Tandanari will prove to be a great success on and off the pitch - and I do think its a great move by the club to tap in to the Japanese market - I'm just worried by our current run of form and lack of cover for Lambert given the way we play at the moment.

Am I the only one that thinks this transfer deal is all about selling shirts in Japan (and maybe Korea as well)? I'm just not convinced a player used to the J League will give us what we need in the English Championship to get us promoted - or that he'll cope with the speed and physicality of the Premier League is we ever get back there either. I can see him frustrating the crowd in the same way that Do Prado does now. I'd be much happier if we were signing Lucas Juktiewitz who has proved he can get goals in the Championship for a bad team.

Brighton fans would argue we only won the game at St Marys due to dodgy refereeing - although I would argue that we won that game despite the referee as he was truly awful. He seemed to get virtually every decision wrong! But we were 1-0 up and would have won anyway!

# blimey you lot are a right bunch of muppets - read it again - at no point did it say we wouldn't bring any players in! Aaron Martin needs playing time to improve and the only place he's going to get a lot of that is probably another club in League 1 - saying that he was great covering for Fonte last night so may get a run in the team if Jose is out injured for a while. But I have a feeling we're still going to sign another centre back Seabourne is probably nowhere near being match fit for the Championship - and I can see him going on loan to get games under his belt - and for the same reason as Martin as we don't have a reserve team to get them game time or match fit Dean and Doble are already on short term loans and Puncheon is already halfway out the door - and Forte is rumoured to be on his way - and Bart is another that needs to move to get games Holmes looks like he'll stay though as his 2 or 3 touches against Bristol City when he came on last night was pure class - so I'll take that one back

Lee Holmes out on loan to a League 1 club Jonno Quick Forte - Walsall for a small feee Bartosz Bialkowski on loan to a League 1 club or back to Poland for a small fee Puncheon to Blackpool in part exchange for Matt Phillips or £ cash to Millwall Aaron Martin out on loan Dan Seabourne out on loan if he is anywhere near fit Harlee Dean on loan to Brentford Ryan Doble out on loan

It will be Jay Roriguez and Lucas Juktiewitz

but Martin O'Neill was in Winchester that infamous time - he was visiting Steve Guppy

We need two strikers really - someone who can provide cover for Lambert - a big man such as Juktiewtiz who can also lead the line - and a fast pacey striker to lead the line and play in front of Lambert such as Maynard. I really think we should have signed Jukiewitz from Coventry on loan - he would have made a big difference today in place of Do Prado. His signing probably would have given the whole club some impetus . And I couldn't see him chickening out of the 50/50 header with Ward like Guly did today! I'd like to see us bring in Juktiewitz and Maynard as early as possible in January - and push on from there!

Guly cost us the win today - chickened out of the header to let Pomey equalise, failed to chase the ball or close down for much of the game!

what about a decent pub in Winchester?

he's your father in-law - he's not your father - fake an illness and stay home to watch the game if he's a rugger b*gger he deserves no less

its on BBC 1 isn't it?

we obviously need to move some players on in January such as Holmes, Forte, Seabourne, Puncheon, Dickson or Harding, Jaidi, Connolly for example to free up some money on the wage bill

My brother-in-law will be in the home end with his cousin. My nephew - his son - has a season ticket at St Marys along with me and my father. We're not taking to Fratton Park for this game though - although he's been there a few times with his Dad.

Nope - they all play football in Scotland which as we have learnt to our cost means they are ****e - a la Neil McCannt and Rudi 'bloody useless' Skacel! just look at Middlesbrough last season if you need further proof! And before you say it Hoovied proves the point as Celtic never really played him -coz he made everybody else look really bad!

And how exactly are they going to get promoted when they are 3rd from bottom and in all probability going to lose Nicky Maynard in the January transfer window? And people think some of our fans are deluded!