egg

As you say, they'll want a "name". It has to be Poch for me.

Glue

Not sure that matters, he did miss it. Any player at any level should have buried that.

Indeed, different view, and I can see yours but I just didn't read what he said as a swipe at us, rather bigging up Villa. I hadn't appreciated until yesterday that he'd chosen not to play previously. Cos of that, and the drop of in performances, I'm glad he's gone.

Barber

You're out by 180 degrees imo. He's talking up his new club. He ain't going to endear himself to Villa and their fans by saying "you're a Step backwards but I needed to move, so here I am" or similar, and he doesn't need to keep is sweet cos he ain't here anymore. If you're right that he's having a swipe at us, are you saying it's ok for fans to disrespect him and say he's shite, a manager to dump him, but that he can't be negative about the club? Too many thinned skin people in this world.

Behave. Sure, he was no Rio Ferdinand, but he wasn't as bad as you make out. Converted to CB and always did pretty well there imo. Personally I'd have kept him as cover. Good luck to the lad.

It didn't say we would...it was a question, nothing more.

Giant

Yes, but your initial point was that of Redmond and Theo (wide players) leave we need to replace them. That's a different point to needing an alternative CF.

What he said ^^^ Theo was injured for ages, and Redmond is off the scene. Neither made the 20 for Leeds or Man United - both out and one is fine with me.

Assuming we've paid £10m for Edozie, he'll be around the first team.

Yep, he's far better than national league. Hopefully he'll do well and find a level somewhere between there and here.

Blimey, he's better than national league. Hope he gets games and a proper move.

Ah, gotcha... cheers. My neck is wound in 😂

Hadn't appreciated taht. Intrigued to know what's gone on if true though. SG said above that we've had issues with Chelsea, then a rumour we've got a bright talent back.

That's the fella who said yesterday that Edozie was off to Leverkusen. Not sure that he's any more reliable than your man Crook.

I think its "let's get ourselves a buffet of players and try them all and see who we like best". It's brave/interesting/mad/exciting though.

Nobody has said he's going anywhere mate. Just said there's been a report. I've said everyone has a price, which they do.

It'd probably cheer you up you miserable sod.

That's the point, everyone has a price. I don't want to see him sold, but if the price is players who'll improve is over all, I'd let him go.

What's it to you if we get a fee or not?! If he's on £70k a week, we'll be paying him almost £3m to not play until next summer. Get him and his wages off our books imo.

What if Chelsea come in and throw us Broja, Gallagher and some cash?

Redmond won't provide that dynamism. Is he realistically going to play this season? I can't see it, hence shifting his wages off the books makes sense to me.

You were giving him to Leeds a minute ago! Make your mind up mate!