I only saw part of the second half and the motd highlights, redmond looked sharp, keen and dangerous to me. Maybe he was carp in the first half, I don't know apart from the brief highlights on the beeb, but second half he looked very good. Obviously it's going to take some time for him to get used to the other players, playing relationships don't develop immediately, but I was pretty impressed. I don't understand the negativity after one prem game.