Jump to content

The 'Otherwise Unremarkable Saints Players Who Became Immortal For One Thing' XI


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

The Poch vs. Koeman thread stirred memories of the 4-0 win over Arsenal that meant the otherwise bog average Cuco Martina will always be remembered for this: 

obTdGHe.gif

Then of course there's Bobby Stokes. Before my time, but I get the impression that he was a fairly unremarkable player who wrote himself into history with the goal that won our only FA Cup. 

Wayne Thomas is another. A not especially great Championship level centre half, but whenever I hear his name I remember being right behind the absolute twatter that he blooted into the top corner from miles out against Ipswich. Played almost 60 times for us but that's his legacy to me. 

Which otherwise undistinguished, mediocre or just downright forgettable players are etched into your memory for doing one thing? 

Edited by Midfield_General
  • Like 3
Posted (edited)

Wayne Thomas v Ipswich (Ah, already mentioned...)

Chris Baird v Cardiff. 

 

That's nearly a back 4.

Edited by Colinjb
  • Like 1
Posted

Tahar El Khalej for his challenge on someone from Newcastle (Dyer I think, who was a bit of an annoying fucker from recollection).

Oscar Goburn - for similar reasons. 

  • Like 2
Posted
20 minutes ago, Midfield_General said:

Then of course there's Bobby Stokes. Before my time, but I get the impression that he was a fairly unremarkable player who wrote himself into history with the goal that won our only FA Cup. 

Wayne Thomas is another. A not especially great Championship level centre half, but whenever I hear his name I remember being right behind the absolute twatter that he blooted into the top corner from miles out against Ipswich. Played almost 60 times for us but that's his legacy to me. 

Which otherwise undistinguished, mediocre or just downright forgettable players are etched into your memory for doing one thing? 

A little bit unfair on Bobby Stokes who’d been around for a few years and always seemed a willing tryer and scored a few without being prolific. 

He was always overshadowed though by the likes of Davies, (and from recollection) Paine and Sydenham when he first came into the side, then by Channon and Osgood by the time of the Cup success.

You’re right though that The Cup Final was his standout moment that he’ll always be remembered for. 

Posted

Here's my XI:

 

Alan Blayney - PL save of the season vs. Newcastle

Cuco Martina - Aforementioned Arsenal Goal

Wayne Thomas - Absolute worldy vs. Ipswich

Tahar El Khalej - The tackle on Dyer

Greg Vignal - 40 yard free kick against Leicester

Jhon Viafara - He sorry he ruin the party

Mario Licka - His missus was gorgeous

Johnny Forte - MK Dons

Gaston Ramirez - The Villa game

Jason Puncheon - Went for a dump

Dani Osvaldo - Put Kompany on his backside, then lobbed a 8'15" keeper

  • Like 1
Posted

Steve De Ridder, great goal at Reading, on his debut everyone thought he was amazing because he was quick, it soon turned out that was all he was, apart from that goal

Mark Hughes, good for everyone else, shite for us, had a goal disallowed though that went in but hit it so hard it came back off the adverting boards behind the goal. A remarkable non goal.

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, Midfield_General said:

The Poch vs. Koeman thread stirred memories of the 4-0 win over Arsenal that meant the otherwise bog average Cuco Martina will always be remembered for this: 

obTdGHe.gif

Then of course there's Bobby Stokes. Before my time, but I get the impression that he was a fairly unremarkable player who wrote himself into history with the goal that won our only FA Cup. 

Wayne Thomas is another. A not especially great Championship level centre half, but whenever I hear his name I remember being right behind the absolute twatter that he blooted into the top corner from miles out against Ipswich. Played almost 60 times for us but that's his legacy to me. 

Which otherwise undistinguished, mediocre or just downright forgettable players are etched into your memory for doing one thing? 

 

1 hour ago, Midfield_General said:

The Poch vs. Koeman thread stirred memories of the 4-0 win over Arsenal that meant the otherwise bog average Cuco Martina will always be remembered for this: 

obTdGHe.gif

Then of course there's Bobby Stokes. Before my time, but I get the impression that he was a fairly unremarkable player who wrote himself into history with the goal that won our only FA Cup. 

Wayne Thomas is another. A not especially great Championship level centre half, but whenever I hear his name I remember being right behind the absolute twatter that he blooted into the top corner from miles out against Ipswich. Played almost 60 times for us but that's his legacy to me. 

Which otherwise undistinguished, mediocre or just downright forgettable players are etched into your memory for doing one thing? 

Cant agree with that Bobby Stokes played for Saints for many seasons before the cup final in the first division plus goals all the way to wembley 

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think he'll make it as an immortal, but Patrick Colleter was a brief left back, presumably when Benali was injured or briefly dropped in 98/99. He had a run of games but only one moment of note, scoring a long range should be saved goal against Charlton in a 6 pointer at The Dell I was at. Always remember his name despite him leaving shortly after that.

  • Like 1
Posted

Barry Manolo for his goal vs Swansea. To be fair though he did more than that including his cup final hat trick vs Man Utd. 

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, Badger said:

Tahar El Khalej for his challenge on someone from Newcastle (Dyer I think, who was a bit of an annoying fucker from recollection).

Think Dyer took legal action against him for that, Tahar nearly chopped him in half

 

-Dexter Blackstock's hat-trick against Colchester (not to mention his stint in goal vs Newcastle)

-Paul Smith's impressive stand in performances when Niemi got injured

  • Like 2
Posted
1 hour ago, explorer saint said:

 

Cant agree with that Bobby Stokes played for Saints for many seasons before the cup final in the first division plus goals all the way to wembley 

Fair play.

As I say, Bobby was before my time, I just know him for the goal so I don't even really know what sort of player he was.

It sounds like he was good, so please could you expand a little bit on his qualities so he can be struck from the record? 

Posted
1 hour ago, Lighthouse said:

Here's my XI:

 

Alan Blayney - PL save of the season vs. Newcastle

Cuco Martina - Aforementioned Arsenal Goal

Wayne Thomas - Absolute worldy vs. Ipswich

Tahar El Khalej - The tackle on Dyer

Greg Vignal - 40 yard free kick against Leicester

Jhon Viafara - He sorry he ruin the party

Mario Licka - His missus was gorgeous

Johnny Forte - MK Dons

Gaston Ramirez - The Villa game

Jason Puncheon - Went for a dump

Dani Osvaldo - Put Kompany on his backside, then lobbed a 8'15" keeper

This is what I'm talking about 

  • Like 1
Posted
40 minutes ago, saintstowin said:

I don't think he'll make it as an immortal, but Patrick Colleter was a brief left back, presumably when Benali was injured or briefly dropped in 98/99. He had a run of games but only one moment of note, scoring a long range should be saved goal against Charlton in a 6 pointer at The Dell I was at. Always remember his name despite him leaving shortly after that.

Didn't he once have a scrap with the entire subs bench of an opposing team?

Posted

Good thread this!

Stuart Ripley scored an absolute beauty, entirely unexpectedly having been shit for us.

Can't remember who it was against.....was at The Dell I think.

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, Turkish said:

Steve De Ridder, great goal at Reading, on his debut everyone thought he was amazing because he was quick, it soon turned out that was all he was, apart from that goal

Mark Hughes, good for everyone else, shite for us, had a goal disallowed though that went in but hit it so hard it came back off the adverting boards behind the goal. A remarkable non goal.

Steve De Ridder only gets into the XI because David Brooks is cup-tied!

  • Haha 1
Posted
12 minutes ago, Midfield_General said:

I've never heard about this - talk me through it

I can't even remember why I was at Upton Park that night (I'm pretty sure it was a night game). I was under the stand on Saint's right wing. Tommy got the ball in his own half over on the left wing and jinked his way round player after player before slamming it home.

I remember thinking at the time that it was by far the best goal I had ever seen and I remember even the Hammers fans applauding. I've got a rotten memory for past goals but this is one I'll never forget. I was sixteen.

  • Like 1
Posted
3 minutes ago, Cumbria Saint said:

I can't even remember why I was at Upton Park that night (I'm pretty sure it was a night game). I was under the stand on Saint's right wing. Tommy got the ball in his own half over on the left wing and jinked his way round player after player before slamming it home.

I remember thinking at the time that it was by far the best goal I had ever seen and I remember even the Hammers fans applauding. I've got a rotten memory for past goals but this is one I'll never forget. I was sixteen.

Magnificent. Here's to Tommy. 

Oscar Gobern has to make the side, surely. "A clumsy challenge."

 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Cumbria Saint said:

I remember thinking at the time that it was by far the best goal I had ever seen and I remember even the Hammers fans applauding. I've got a rotten memory for past goals but this is one I'll never forget. I was sixteen.

I see Brian Hayward from the Echo remembers it much as I did....

Brian Hayward in the next day’s Echo described it “ Tommy Jenkins took possession of the ball just inside Saints half, a position West Ham must surely have regarded as harmless. But nothing was further than the truth. With uncanny control, as if the ball was attached to his boot, Jenkins tricked four men in a bewildering run which left Billy Bonds, Peter Bennett, Alan Stephenson and Bobby Moore stranded in his wake. By this time Jenkins had penetrated the West Ham penalty area and shot from his left foot. The ball seemed to burst through Peter Grotier before settling snugly in the back of the net. The West Ham crowd always appreciative of skill were enraptured by the goal. Their reaction was spontaneous and their applause generous and sincere, for this was individual brilliance and artistry”.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...