No, I don't think he is. There are a few of us now who actually dare to question the skills of a player most on here have wet dreams about. For me, as I have said ad infinitum, his hesitancy at the back causes a big problem with the back four, which is exploited by teams who just look at a few videos. It's like wicket keepers - the best ones you don't notice. It's the ones who do the Match of the Day saves and then **** up the easy ones you want to watch out for. For me, that's Davis. Could we lure Maik Taylor back?