sadoldgit Posted Thursday at 23:47 Posted Thursday at 23:47 3 hours ago, Colinjb said: Putting a name out there, entirely based on the spur of the moment and probably nothing to do with us. Troy Parrott. Will he play off the shoulder of Long John Silver? 1 2
SaintLondon Posted yesterday at 09:02 Posted yesterday at 09:02 Seen a report we might cancel Jelert's loan in Jan - what is happening there? I thought he has looked ok?
tdmickey3 Posted yesterday at 09:21 Posted yesterday at 09:21 12 hours ago, Colinjb said: Putting a name out there, entirely based on the spur of the moment and probably nothing to do with us. Troy Parrott. Nah, he just copies what everyone else says 1 1
UpweySaint Posted yesterday at 09:26 Posted yesterday at 09:26 22 minutes ago, SaintLondon said: Seen a report we might cancel Jelert's loan in Jan - what is happening there? I thought he has looked ok? Injuries have limited his game time severely which could be a factor I guess? Possible he just hasn’t settled either. We have seen very little of him but he does look decent if he can stay fit (god that feels a familiar refrain!) 2
S-Clarke Posted yesterday at 09:38 Posted yesterday at 09:38 11 minutes ago, UpweySaint said: Injuries have limited his game time severely which could be a factor I guess? Possible he just hasn’t settled either. We have seen very little of him but he does look decent if he can stay fit (god that feels a familiar refrain!) I read something that suggest club sources feel he is too 'light weight' for the Championship. It should have been obvious when they were scouting him, no? I think he's a good player with time and space, but it looks like he could snap in half with a bad tackle. 1
SNSUN Posted yesterday at 11:18 Posted yesterday at 11:18 Playing as Arsenal on FM22 and Mika Biereth and Folarin Balogun are banging them in for me. In the real world both play for Monaco and score a fair amount and are still a good age. That's my scouting done. Make it happen Saints. 😝
UpweySaint Posted yesterday at 12:03 Posted yesterday at 12:03 2 hours ago, S-Clarke said: I read something that suggest club sources feel he is too 'light weight' for the Championship. It should have been obvious when they were scouting him, no? I think he's a good player with time and space, but it looks like he could snap in half with a bad tackle. As you say, bizarre if that’s the case. Physicality is surely something you can get a good sense of ahead of getting a player in - it’s not something a little more subjective like personality type/aptitude. We’re not blessed with options so I would like to see more of him should he stay and be able to get fit. He does look more than decent for this level.
Chez Posted yesterday at 13:14 Posted yesterday at 13:14 4 hours ago, SaintLondon said: Seen a report we might cancel Jelert's loan in Jan - what is happening there? I thought he has looked ok? It might be our decision, but if he is not getting games, maybe the player and/or his parent club want to cancel the loan. It might be out of our hands if the loan contract requires he plays a certain number of games. I don't think I have seen him. Is he actually a left back or right back?
Patches O Houlihan Posted yesterday at 13:29 Posted yesterday at 13:29 (edited) I see JWP has been linked again. We know that he can play alongside Oriel, but it would be a shame to squeeze Shea Charles & Casper Jander from playing time. That salary is probably better spent with a striker. We have Scienza for free kicks (and Manning bizarrely). But if we did get promoted it would be lovely to see him break Beckham's PL free kick record in a Saints shirt. Would he even come? Alongside Oriel he would definitely drive up professional standards in the dressing room. Thoughts? Edited yesterday at 13:45 by Patches O Houlihan extra
Hopper Posted yesterday at 13:41 Posted yesterday at 13:41 26 minutes ago, Chez said: It might be our decision, but if he is not getting games, maybe the player and/or his parent club want to cancel the loan. It might be out of our hands if the loan contract requires he plays a certain number of games. I don't think I have seen him. Is he actually a left back or right back? Can play either, has looked good when he's played buy picked up a muscle strain a couple of matches back.
Patches O Houlihan Posted yesterday at 13:44 Posted yesterday at 13:44 He looked good technically but did look like he would be muscled off the ball regularly in the Championship. Its like Sports Republic are size blind: They spot the technical ability, and assume that they've paid a bargain price, failing to realise it is because the player will struggle with the English game which must be a big driver of player pricing. 1
saintant Posted yesterday at 13:49 Posted yesterday at 13:49 4 hours ago, S-Clarke said: I read something that suggest club sources feel he is too 'light weight' for the Championship. It should have been obvious when they were scouting him, no? I think he's a good player with time and space, but it looks like he could snap in half with a bad tackle. We continue to recruit players who are too lightweight. Spors suggested he was going to fix this but he has done little other than signing Quarshie who is one for the future and the recent signing of Romeu. Spors should be studying other clubs like Bournemouth, Brentford, Palace and Sunderland. We have far too many shrinking violets who shirk at the first sign of a physical battle. 1
saintant Posted yesterday at 13:51 Posted yesterday at 13:51 20 minutes ago, Patches O Houlihan said: I see JWP has been linked again. We know that he can play alongside Oriel, but it would be a shame to squeeze Shea Charles & Casper Jander from playing time. That salary is probably better spent with a striker. We have Scienza for free kicks (and Manning bizarrely). But if we did get promoted it would be lovely to see him break Beckham's PL free kick record in a Saints shirt. Would he even come? Thoughts? No thanks. Another slow, small player who can't compete physically is the last thing we need. 2
Fabrice29 Posted yesterday at 15:07 Posted yesterday at 15:07 1 hour ago, Patches O Houlihan said: I see JWP has been linked again. We know that he can play alongside Oriel, but it would be a shame to squeeze Shea Charles & Casper Jander from playing time. That salary is probably better spent with a striker. We have Scienza for free kicks (and Manning bizarrely). But if we did get promoted it would be lovely to see him break Beckham's PL free kick record in a Saints shirt. Would he even come? Alongside Oriel he would definitely drive up professional standards in the dressing room. Thoughts? Yeah don’t really understand the fascination with beefing up the midfield when we have plenty of options in there. Fitness issues in there are an issue though. Plus it’s lovely PR play from the club with him and OR signing, so I suspect that’s behind any motivation to do it. Think it smacks of playing to the crowd which Solak especially is keen to do.
Saint Pete Posted yesterday at 15:25 Posted yesterday at 15:25 1 hour ago, Patches O Houlihan said: I see JWP has been linked again. We know that he can play alongside Oriel, but it would be a shame to squeeze Shea Charles & Casper Jander from playing time. That salary is probably better spent with a striker. We have Scienza for free kicks (and Manning bizarrely). But if we did get promoted it would be lovely to see him break Beckham's PL free kick record in a Saints shirt. Would he even come? Alongside Oriel he would definitely drive up professional standards in the dressing room. Thoughts? He would probably still improve us but having already re-signed an experienced Central midfielder in Romeu the timing doesn't feel right for him to return now, would have definitely taken him at the start of the season if he was available then. Agree that the salary would be better spent on improving our striking options now and let Jander and Charles come on more with the help of Romeu providing the know how in midfield.
sadoldgit Posted yesterday at 15:56 Posted yesterday at 15:56 6 hours ago, SaintLondon said: Seen a report we might cancel Jelert's loan in Jan - what is happening there? I thought he has looked ok? Perhaps the plan is to bring Bree back? 3
Willo of Whiteley Posted yesterday at 18:14 Posted yesterday at 18:14 I’d take James Ward-Prwose back comfortably. Let’s be brutally honest Shea Charles isn’t signing a new contract so we’ll be cashing in on him next summer. Flynn Downes - quite simply, I hope he leaves. I’m extremely confident we won’t be signing a goalkeeper, because it’ll be another admission of poor business by Sport Republic (for Gavin Bazunu). I’m struggling to see what Spors and Sport Republic will do regarding signings in January, I don’t see them many many, if any. But I’m sure they’ll be keen to still try and offload a few such as Sam Edozie and Joe Aribo.
Chez Posted yesterday at 18:39 Posted yesterday at 18:39 23 minutes ago, Willo of Whiteley said: I’d take James Ward-Prwose back comfortably. Let’s be brutally honest Shea Charles isn’t signing a new contract so we’ll be cashing in on him next summer. Flynn Downes - quite simply, I hope he leaves. I’m extremely confident we won’t be signing a goalkeeper, because it’ll be another admission of poor business by Sport Republic (for Gavin Bazunu). I’m struggling to see what Spors and Sport Republic will do regarding signings in January, I don’t see them many many, if any. But I’m sure they’ll be keen to still try and offload a few such as Sam Edozie and Joe Aribo. they spent a fair amount in the summer, so if they only loan a striker in January, that works for me. 2
Hamwic Posted 10 hours ago Posted 10 hours ago Apparently Newcastle are interested in James Trafford in January. Would that mean a timely return for Ramsdale?
hypochondriac Posted 9 hours ago Posted 9 hours ago If i was in charge I'd loan out one of our keepers and get the Sunderland keeper in on loan. I'd get a tall striker possibly on loan and maybe jwp if he wants to come. I'd offload Aribo and Edozie and maybe Downes, bring back Bree and it looks like Jelert is going back for some odd reason. With everyone fit my team would be: Patterson Bree/Mads Wood/Stephens THB Wellington Romeu/jwp Charles/Jander Fellows/Armstrong Scienza/Robinson Azaz New striker/Stewart
JohnnyShearer2.0 Posted 8 hours ago Posted 8 hours ago 13 minutes ago, hypochondriac said: If i was in charge I'd loan out one of our keepers and get the Sunderland keeper in on loan. I'd get a tall striker possibly on loan and maybe jwp if he wants to come. I'd offload Aribo and Edozie and maybe Downes, bring back Bree and it looks like Jelert is going back for some odd reason. With everyone fit my team would be: Patterson Bree/Mads Wood/Stephens THB Wellington Romeu/jwp Charles/Jander Fellows/Armstrong Scienza/Robinson Azaz New striker/Stewart Or get Ramsdale back if Newcastle get Trafford. His world cup dream is dead.
hypochondriac Posted 8 hours ago Posted 8 hours ago Just now, JohnnyShearer2.0 said: Or get Ramsdale back if Newcastle get Trafford. His world cup dream is dead. Very much doubt that's going to happen.
S-Clarke Posted 8 hours ago Posted 8 hours ago Just now, JohnnyShearer2.0 said: Or get Ramsdale back if Newcastle get Trafford. His world cup dream is dead. Wages would stop us doing that. We can't pay anyone 100 odd k in the Champ. If Newcastle do dump him back, we will have to find another taker for 6 months pretty sharpish (or a sale)
hypochondriac Posted 8 hours ago Posted 8 hours ago 1 minute ago, S-Clarke said: Wages would stop us doing that. We can't pay anyone 100 odd k in the Champ. If Newcastle do dump him back, we will have to find another taker for 6 months pretty sharpish (or a sale) Doubt they will be dumping him given they've paid money to use him for the season.
Matthew Le God Posted 6 hours ago Posted 6 hours ago 1 hour ago, S-Clarke said: Wages would stop us doing that. We can't pay anyone 100 odd k in the Champ. If Newcastle do dump him back, we will have to find another taker for 6 months pretty sharpish (or a sale) He won't be on that now for us. We have relegation wage reduction clauses. Circa 40%.
spyinthesky Posted 5 hours ago Posted 5 hours ago 48 minutes ago, Matthew Le God said: He won't be on that now for us. We have relegation wage reduction clauses. Circa 40%. MLG Even at 40%+, our squad wages will still be at the very top end of wages paid in the Championship. I understand the loan fee for Ramsdale was between £3-£4m which, if true, is a tidy sum and I guess Saints will allow him to find another club at the end of this season and try to recoup most of the £22m, reportedly, we paid for him. It would be interesting to learn how much loan fees were for: Smallbone (Millwall) Taylor (WBA) Brerton Diaz (Derby) Bella Kotcha (Verona) Sugawara (Bremen) Sanda (???) Probably £2-£3m in total to add to Ramsdale say £3m and say £95m from the sale of Dibling/Fernandez/Bednerak/Tall Paul and Sulemana. So say £100m revenue from sales and around £46m from inward transfers. That leaves us with a big squad which probably sits on our books at an overall cost of around £168m, with another £40m 'worth' of players out on loan. The overall squad expenditure certainly doesnt seem to be translating to value on the field of play!!
OldNick Posted 5 hours ago Posted 5 hours ago On 14/11/2025 at 09:38, S-Clarke said: I read something that suggest club sources feel he is too 'light weight' for the Championship. It should have been obvious when they were scouting him, no? I think he's a good player with time and space, but it looks like he could snap in half with a bad tackle. He does look very lightweight and a schoolboy
Matthew Le God Posted 4 hours ago Posted 4 hours ago 1 hour ago, spyinthesky said: MLG Even at 40%+, our squad wages will still be at the very top end of wages paid in the Championship. I didn't say otherwise. I was only saying Ramsdale won't be on £100k+ p/w with us currently. 1
benjii Posted 3 hours ago Posted 3 hours ago 1 hour ago, Matthew Le God said: I didn't say otherwise. I was only saying Ramsdale won't be on £100k+ p/w with us currently. He didn't say you said otherwise.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now