Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
On 20/04/2022 at 15:56, HKsaint said:

Should not let Salisu get close to the squad before he signs a new contract.  

Salisu is clearly quality just having a bad patch. Get him a new contract now IMO. Even in this poor form ,he's better than Beg and Stephens.

Posted
4 hours ago, Bad Wolf said:

Salisu is clearly quality just having a bad patch. Get him a new contract now IMO. Even in this poor form ,he's better than Beg and Stephens.

Tosh. He is proving every week that he is not a very good player and no better than any of the others.

  • Haha 1
  • Confused 2
  • Sad 1
Posted
11 hours ago, Charlie Wayman said:

Tosh. He is proving every week that he is not a very good player and no better than any of the others.

😂😂😂😂😂

Posted
14 hours ago, Charlie Wayman said:

Tosh. He is proving every week that he is not a very good player and no better than any of the others.

I suggest watching some of the games around Christmas time. Also Leeds at home, he put in a better performance than I've EVER seen from the other two.

  • Like 1
Posted
19 hours ago, Bad Wolf said:

Salisu is clearly quality just having a bad patch. Get him a new contract now IMO. Even in this poor form ,he's better than Beg and Stephens.

That could be down to fasting in Ramadan.

  • Like 2
Posted
Just now, DT said:

Fraser is off and we’re keeping McCarthy. Club is run by morons

Well we're getting a new number one so which one do you want sat on the bench getting paid to do nothing? They're both utterly dreadful (it's just that Forster gets away with it week after week and McCarthy is ridiculed for every single little thing that goes wrong)

Posted
Just now, Bad Wolf said:

Well we're getting a new number one so which one do you want sat on the bench getting paid to do nothing? They're both utterly dreadful (it's just that Forster gets away with it week after week and McCarthy is ridiculed for every single little thing that goes wrong)

Telegraph report says we’re after a number two. If McCarthy is number one I’m looking at relegation odds for next season

  • Like 2
Posted
Just now, DT said:

Telegraph report says we’re after a number two. If McCarthy is number one I’m looking at relegation odds for next season

Absolute bloody calamity

  • Like 4
Posted
Just now, DT said:

Telegraph report says we’re after a number two. If McCarthy is number one I’m looking at relegation odds for next season

If that's the case then I'll concur with you but I don't for one minute believe it is. You also have to consider the fact that Forster has had a torrid time with us over the last 5 years or so and there's a good chance he wants to move whereas McCarthy is probably happy to play second fiddle and stay with us.

Posted
29 minutes ago, Bad Wolf said:

If that's the case then I'll concur with you but I don't for one minute believe it is. You also have to consider the fact that Forster has had a torrid time with us over the last 5 years or so and there's a good chance he wants to move whereas McCarthy is probably happy to play second fiddle and stay with us.

Obvously we can only start with 11 on the pitch, and for keepers it's even worse as they have no psitional flexibility, but anyone "happy" to play second fiddle in any postion should be shipped out asap. Nothing but determination to prove their worth as first choice should be acceptable.

Posted
Just now, Wurzel said:

Obvously we can only start with 11 on the pitch, and for keepers it's even worse as they have no psitional flexibility, but anyone "happy" to play second fiddle in any postion should be shipped out asap. Nothing but determination to prove their worth as first choice should be acceptable.

Personally I'd rather be paid to sit around doing nothing at Southampton than go and be a star man at say Wigan, which is probably about the level that McCarthy would end up at if he left.

Players are employees. Nothing more, nothing less.

Posted
17 minutes ago, Bad Wolf said:

Personally I'd rather be paid to sit around doing nothing at Southampton than go and be a star man at say Wigan, which is probably about the level that McCarthy would end up at if he left.

Players are employees. Nothing more, nothing less.

He would be number two to Ben Amos at Wigan

  • Like 1
Posted
8 minutes ago, DT said:

He would be number two to Ben Amos at Wigan

I didn't mean literally Wigan, I meant someone like that. Top of League One or bottom of The Championship. Amos is a very good keeper at that level though tbf. The Plymouth keeper is very good too. I can't remember his name but he's only 21 or something.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Bad Wolf said:

I didn't mean literally Wigan, I meant someone like that. Top of League One or bottom of The Championship. Amos is a very good keeper at that level though tbf. The Plymouth keeper is very good too. I can't remember his name but he's only 21 or something.

Yeah, was only joshing

Posted
Just now, DT said:

Yeah, was only joshing

But in terms of other options I find it hard to think of a worse keeper than McCarthy. Certainly none from the Prem

  • Like 1
Posted
1 minute ago, DT said:

But in terms of other options I find it hard to think of a worse keeper than McCarthy. Certainly none from the Prem

Krul isn't having a good time. In general, I've been a big fan over the years but maybe him? I honestly don't think there are many worse than Forster either. Forster is better than McCarthy but if that's our benchmark, we're in trouble.

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
7 hours ago, Wurzel said:

Obvously we can only start with 11 on the pitch, and for keepers it's even worse as they have no psitional flexibility, but anyone "happy" to play second fiddle in any postion should be shipped out asap. Nothing but determination to prove their worth as first choice should be acceptable.

I remember a Neil Moss interview, where he wanted to make the keepers spot on the bench his own. 🙂

Edited by Holmes_and_Watson
Posted
6 hours ago, DT said:

Telegraph report says we’re after a number two. If McCarthy is number one I’m looking at relegation odds for next season

And why do you believe the Torygraph? It's a rag, and they have zero information on Saints, a bit like their knowledge of anything.

  • Like 2
Posted
13 hours ago, VectisSaint said:

And why do you believe the Torygraph? It's a rag, and they have zero information on Saints, a bit like their knowledge of anything.

A bit harsh Vectis. The DT may have a Tory bias but they are no worse in reporting Soccer rumours than the other Newspapers. Normal coverage about other matters, including Sport is very good.

Posted
1 minute ago, rooney said:

A bit harsh Vectis. The DT may have a Tory bias but they are no worse in reporting Soccer rumours than the other Newspapers. Normal coverage about other matters, including Sport is very good.

🤣

Posted
On 26/04/2022 at 13:20, DT said:

Telegraph report says we’re after a number two. 

I don't doubt that report. McCarthy was given a new contract when he was our number 1, to be our number 1.  We'll sign a younger and cheaper keeper. Let's hope that he does a better job of replacing McCarthy than Gunn did. 

  • Like 1
Posted
6 minutes ago, Chez said:

I don't doubt that report. McCarthy was given a new contract when he was our number 1, to be our number 1.  We'll sign a younger and cheaper keeper. Let's hope that he does a better job of replacing McCarthy than Gunn did. 

Given our number one is not very good, we are effectively after someone shit. Great. 

  • Like 2
Posted
On 26/04/2022 at 14:35, Bad Wolf said:

Krul isn't having a good time. In general, I've been a big fan over the years but maybe him? I honestly don't think there are many worse than Forster either. Forster is better than McCarthy but if that's our benchmark, we're in trouble.

Gareth Southgate called one of those keepers up to play for England. 

Posted
16 hours ago, DT said:

Given our number one is not very good, we are effectively after someone shit. Great. 

Younger and cheaper doesn't mean shitter. Besides, if McCarthy is as bad as you make out, then the new keeper, whoever he is, will most likely be better than him.

Posted
16 hours ago, DT said:

Gareth Southgate called one of those keepers up to play for England. 

Actually Southgate has called both of them up for England, just that one was more recently. As I said, hardly a ringing endorsement, the pool of England qualified keepers is not very deep.

Posted

I get it. Some people think McCarthy is marginally less poor than Forster. I think it's the other way around. But either way I find it disappointing that the club has a lack of ambition to actually improve here in a key position. It's a symptom of our general inability to 'kick on'. Seems a bit engrained, but I suppose when you admit you're a place where youngsters can get a chance before moving on, that comes as a side effect.

Posted

Had our financial chappy round the other day - he was with McCarthy at Reading and said even as a youngster he was sublime one moment then wishy washy all over the place the next and the one after. He said he still sees that trait when watching him between the sticks.

 

Posted

our keepers should be the best in the prem,,they have heaps of work to do match day,especially pulling the ball out of the net.

  • Like 1
Posted
On 04/05/2022 at 20:37, SuperSAINT said:

Not too surprising, but Benni Smales-Braithwaite & Ramello Mitchell have both said they leaving on Instagram.

Both obviously out of contract on @Over land and sea's opening post.

As has Ethan Burnett as well

I'll update the opening post for the 22-23 season once we have something official (assuming there is something official!) - unlikely to be before the last first team match. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Salary/Contract details courtesy of SalarySports.com

                        Age.........Per week......Per Year.......Contract
JWP..................26...........£100k...........£5.2m............6/26.
Redmond.........27.............£74k............£3.8m............6/23.
Walcott............32.............£72k............£3.7m............6/22.
Forster.............33.............£72k............£3.7m............6/22.
Bednerak.........25.............£60k........... £3.1m...........6/25.
Romeu.............29.............£59k.............£3.0m..........6/23.
Elyonoussi.......26.............£59k.............£3.0m..........6/23.
Long.................34.............£58k.............£3.0m..........6/22.
S. Armstrong...29.............£58k.............£3.0m...........6/24.
A. Armstrong...24.............£58k.............£3.0m...........6/25.
Adams.............24..............£52k............£2.7m............6/24.
McCarthy........31..............£52k.............£2.7m............6/22. (but recently extended?)
KWP.................24.............£50k.............£2.6m............6/25.
Lyanco.............24.............£50k.............£2.6m............6/25.
Stephens.........27..............£50k............£2.6m.............6/22.
Diallo................22.............£41k.............£2.1m..............6/24
Peraud.............23.............£38k.............£2.0m............6/25.
Salisu...............22.............£39k.............£2.0m............6/24.
Djneppo...........23.............£34k.............£1.7m.............6/24.
Valery...............22.............£16k..............£832k............6/23.
Tella..................21...............£9k..............£468k............6/23.
Broja..................19...............£8.5k ..........£442k............Loan.
Livramento.......18................£7k..............£364k............6/26.
Smallbone........21................£6k..............£312k.............6/24.
Simeu................19................£5.4k...........£281k.............6/24.
Caleb Watts......19................£3.4k...........£177k.............6/23.
Lancashire........32...............£1.8k.............£94k..............6/22.
H. Lewis............23...............£1.2k.............£62k..............6/22.
J. Byecroft.........19...............£1.1k..............£57k...............6/24

Total Players salaries including Youth team etc= £60m

Based on the above I am sure people will have their own views on individual players value to the club.
There are some who seem excessively well paid for their contribution and others who will expect to see an increase.
It is assumed there may be some additional payments ie appearance money, bonuses etc which may not be included within the above .
It is perhaps sobering to note that the combined salaries of Ronald, De Gea and Sancho at Man Utd total £64m!!

Posted
5 hours ago, spyinthesky said:

Salary/Contract details courtesy of SalarySports.com

                        Age.........Per week......Per Year.......Contract
JWP..................26...........£100k...........£5.2m............6/26.
Redmond.........27.............£74k............£3.8m............6/23.
Walcott............32.............£72k............£3.7m............6/22.
Forster.............33.............£72k............£3.7m............6/22.
Bednerak.........25.............£60k........... £3.1m...........6/25.
Romeu.............29.............£59k.............£3.0m..........6/23.
Elyonoussi.......26.............£59k.............£3.0m..........6/23.
Long.................34.............£58k.............£3.0m..........6/22.
S. Armstrong...29.............£58k.............£3.0m...........6/24.
A. Armstrong...24.............£58k.............£3.0m...........6/25.
Adams.............24..............£52k............£2.7m............6/24.
McCarthy........31..............£52k.............£2.7m............6/22. (but recently extended?)
KWP.................24.............£50k.............£2.6m............6/25.
Lyanco.............24.............£50k.............£2.6m............6/25.
Stephens.........27..............£50k............£2.6m.............6/22.
Diallo................22.............£41k.............£2.1m..............6/24
Peraud.............23.............£38k.............£2.0m............6/25.
Salisu...............22.............£39k.............£2.0m............6/24.
Djneppo...........23.............£34k.............£1.7m.............6/24.
Valery...............22.............£16k..............£832k............6/23.
Tella..................21...............£9k..............£468k............6/23.
Broja..................19...............£8.5k ..........£442k............Loan.
Livramento.......18................£7k..............£364k............6/26.
Smallbone........21................£6k..............£312k.............6/24.
Simeu................19................£5.4k...........£281k.............6/24.
Caleb Watts......19................£3.4k...........£177k.............6/23.
Lancashire........32...............£1.8k.............£94k..............6/22.
H. Lewis............23...............£1.2k.............£62k..............6/22.
J. Byecroft.........19...............£1.1k..............£57k...............6/24

Total Players salaries including Youth team etc= £60m

Based on the above I am sure people will have their own views on individual players value to the club.
There are some who seem excessively well paid for their contribution and others who will expect to see an increase.
It is assumed there may be some additional payments ie appearance money, bonuses etc which may not be included within the above .
It is perhaps sobering to note that the combined salaries of Ronald, De Gea and Sancho at Man Utd total £64m!!

Which idiot agreed to give Walcott an annual salary of £3.7million 🙂

  • Like 1
Posted

Just to add an addendum to my OP, the club benefitted by the departure of Ings, Vestergaard, Bertrand, Lemina and Hoedt to the tune of approx £250k per week ie £13m per annum in salary terms.

Posted
On 07/05/2022 at 12:21, spyinthesky said:

Salary/Contract details courtesy of SalarySports.com

                        Age.........Per week......Per Year.......Contract
JWP..................26...........£100k...........£5.2m............6/26.
Redmond.........27.............£74k............£3.8m............6/23.
Walcott............32.............£72k............£3.7m............6/22.
Forster.............33.............£72k............£3.7m............6/22.
Bednerak.........25.............£60k........... £3.1m...........6/25.
Romeu.............29.............£59k.............£3.0m..........6/23.
Elyonoussi.......26.............£59k.............£3.0m..........6/23.
Long.................34.............£58k.............£3.0m..........6/22.
S. Armstrong...29.............£58k.............£3.0m...........6/24.
A. Armstrong...24.............£58k.............£3.0m...........6/25.
Adams.............24..............£52k............£2.7m............6/24.
McCarthy........31..............£52k.............£2.7m............6/22. (but recently extended?)
KWP.................24.............£50k.............£2.6m............6/25.
Lyanco.............24.............£50k.............£2.6m............6/25.
Stephens.........27..............£50k............£2.6m.............6/22.
Diallo................22.............£41k.............£2.1m..............6/24
Peraud.............23.............£38k.............£2.0m............6/25.
Salisu...............22.............£39k.............£2.0m............6/24.
Djneppo...........23.............£34k.............£1.7m.............6/24.
Valery...............22.............£16k..............£832k............6/23.
Tella..................21...............£9k..............£468k............6/23.
Broja..................19...............£8.5k ..........£442k............Loan.
Livramento.......18................£7k..............£364k............6/26.
Smallbone........21................£6k..............£312k.............6/24.
Simeu................19................£5.4k...........£281k.............6/24.
Caleb Watts......19................£3.4k...........£177k.............6/23.
Lancashire........32...............£1.8k.............£94k..............6/22.
H. Lewis............23...............£1.2k.............£62k..............6/22.
J. Byecroft.........19...............£1.1k..............£57k...............6/24

Total Players salaries including Youth team etc= £60m

Based on the above I am sure people will have their own views on individual players value to the club.
There are some who seem excessively well paid for their contribution and others who will expect to see an increase.
It is assumed there may be some additional payments ie appearance money, bonuses etc which may not be included within the above .
It is perhaps sobering to note that the combined salaries of Ronald, De Gea and Sancho at Man Utd total £64m!!

 

On 07/05/2022 at 18:02, Teddeer said:

Which idiot agreed to give Walcott an annual salary of £3.7million 🙂

Interestingly, £13m of that potentially disappears on July 1st, giving power to the war chest over the summer. However, whilst that funds wages, it doesn't fund the purchase. Looking at the numbers, one sees why the Club wants to do another Livramento type deal. 

Equally, does one presume from this that everyone else is on under a grand a week? If that's the case, I'm guessing, a lot of the B team aren't picking up much more than the average national wage. Even Harry Lewis, a 'genuine' first team squad player, just about, is more than making a living, but not exactly building for his retirement.

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Redmond and Walcott !!!! Fkin hell, no wonder they want rid of those two who are both stealing a living. No wonder Redmond is always smirking, he’s taking the piss. Whoever thought either was worth that much needs a kick up the arse.

Posted
On 03/05/2022 at 10:14, DT said:

I get it. Some people think McCarthy is marginally less poor than Forster. I think it's the other way around. But either way I find it disappointing that the club has a lack of ambition to actually improve here in a key position. It's a symptom of our general inability to 'kick on'. 

I agree. I understand that not having transfer funds perhaps limits who we can bring in, but it shouts "we don't think we can do better", "we don't trust our scouting to improve us" - I am oversimplifying things, I know.

If a player has had `three/four/five' years with us, and no bigger club has bought them in that time, is that an indication that they ain't all that, and thus rather than giving them a new contact, we should be cutting them lose rather than offer a new contract? By allowing them to leave, we open a slot for the next guy, who, rather than be just OK, could be the next big thing - and thus could make us money, not just cost us money?

If the business model is based on us buying cheap, selling high, where does a player that doesn't ever sell/provide a return on investment fit in? Or will there always be a need for `our level players' that just aren't good enough to attract offers from richer clubs?

I guess there aren't lots of buyers out there. And only the absolute very best ever get bought mid contract. Making money out of players is thus getting harder and harder. If thats the case though, should we not be picking up more out of contract players?

I am still annoyed we didn't sign Omar Richards on a free last summer, all be it Bayern Munich is a different weight class.

  • Like 1
Posted
On 07/05/2022 at 12:21, spyinthesky said:

Salary/Contract details courtesy of SalarySports.com

                        Age.........Per week......Per Year.......Contract
JWP..................26...........£100k...........£5.2m............6/26.
Redmond.........27.............£74k............£3.8m............6/23.
Walcott............32.............£72k............£3.7m............6/22.
Forster.............33.............£72k............£3.7m............6/22.
Bednerak.........25.............£60k........... £3.1m...........6/25.
Romeu.............29.............£59k.............£3.0m..........6/23.
Elyonoussi.......26.............£59k.............£3.0m..........6/23.
Long.................34.............£58k.............£3.0m..........6/22.
S. Armstrong...29.............£58k.............£3.0m...........6/24.
A. Armstrong...24.............£58k.............£3.0m...........6/25.
Adams.............24..............£52k............£2.7m............6/24.
McCarthy........31..............£52k.............£2.7m............6/22. (but recently extended?)
KWP.................24.............£50k.............£2.6m............6/25.
Lyanco.............24.............£50k.............£2.6m............6/25.
Stephens.........27..............£50k............£2.6m.............6/22.
Diallo................22.............£41k.............£2.1m..............6/24
Peraud.............23.............£38k.............£2.0m............6/25.
Salisu...............22.............£39k.............£2.0m............6/24.
Djneppo...........23.............£34k.............£1.7m.............6/24.
Valery...............22.............£16k..............£832k............6/23.
Tella..................21...............£9k..............£468k............6/23.
Broja..................19...............£8.5k ..........£442k............Loan.
Livramento.......18................£7k..............£364k............6/26.
Smallbone........21................£6k..............£312k.............6/24.
Simeu................19................£5.4k...........£281k.............6/24.
Caleb Watts......19................£3.4k...........£177k.............6/23.
Lancashire........32...............£1.8k.............£94k..............6/22.
H. Lewis............23...............£1.2k.............£62k..............6/22.
J. Byecroft.........19...............£1.1k..............£57k...............6/24

Total Players salaries including Youth team etc= £60m

Based on the above I am sure people will have their own views on individual players value to the club.
There are some who seem excessively well paid for their contribution and others who will expect to see an increase.
It is assumed there may be some additional payments ie appearance money, bonuses etc which may not be included within the above .
It is perhaps sobering to note that the combined salaries of Ronald, De Gea and Sancho at Man Utd total £64m!!

As if giving Long that 2 year extension wasn’t bad enough the guy is earning £58k a week!? Fucking hell. Don’t get me started on Bednerak and Moi either, what a joke.

  • Like 2

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...