Daniel Peretz

[pimpin4rizeal]

23 hours ago, coalman said:

He was definitely our best 'keeper last year. Saying he was our best player seems like a stretch when compared to Fernandes.

Personally I think ramsdale was more important to us then fernandes was .. fernandes only had 3 goals 3 assists whilst being good on the eye his play didn’t really help us a lot .. Rambo stopped us getting some absolute hammerings and was a big factor in the games we did pick up points 

[coalman]

29 minutes ago, pimpin4rizeal said:

Personally I think ramsdale was more important to us then fernandes was .. fernandes only had 3 goals 3 assists whilst being good on the eye his play didn’t really help us a lot .. Rambo stopped us getting some absolute hammerings and was a big factor in the games we did pick up points 

I think we'll have to disagree on that one. Ramsdale's save percentage was 65% last season for us. This season, for Newcastle, it's 61% which is the third lowest in the league. The top keepers in the premier league have a save percentage above 70%.

For a much smaller sample size - McCarthy had a save percentage last season of 68% in the Premier League.

[pimpin4rizeal]

6 hours ago, coalman said:

I think we'll have to disagree on that one. Ramsdale's save percentage was 65% last season for us. This season, for Newcastle, it's 61% which is the third lowest in the league. The top keepers in the premier league have a save percentage above 70%.

For a much smaller sample size - McCarthy had a save percentage last season of 68% in the Premier League.

Whilst the stats are usually a good indicator I’m not sure this matches up in the same way it does with baz . Looking back through the ramsdale thread most people seemed to think he was super and how it was a shame we finally got the gkposition right but in a shit team .. I can’t be bothered to go back and analyse every goal but I’m sure the suicide passing around the back line didn’t help his stats 

[HKsaint]

I would want Peretz rather than Ramsdale to be our goalkeeper next season. 

[Jack]

5 hours ago, HKsaint said:

I would want Peretz rather than Ramsdale to be our goalkeeper next season. 

He’s good enough. Then add that his wages will be far less and we could get a decent fee for selling Ramsdale, it’s a no brainer. I wonder if it rides on us going up though, he may well have better offers if we don’t 

[Miltonaggro]

Ramsdale is a good prem level keeper, and Peretz looks like he is. The deciding factor for me is communication, and Peretz wins here. Since his first game he has been constantly talking to / positioning central defence through to central midfield every game, and is a huge part of our overall defensive improvement. You can see the appreciation the likes of THB, Stephens, Bree, Manning and Downes have for this.