Jump to content

Posh Owner says Saints' Mackail-Smith bid "Worst he's ever seen"


Saint-Armstrong

Recommended Posts

I was on Twitter earlier today, and I had a little tease with the Peterborough owner, and he decided to start Tweeting me about Saints this is definitely his official account as it is linked to his site.

 

The conversation began:

@ConnorArmstrong

@DMAC102 A centre back, and another striker perhaps. All the best next season, you made L1 exciting and unpredictable for sure!!

19 minutes ago via web

 

Reply:

@DMAC102

@ConnorArmstrong Cheers pal.. Maybe 5-5 next time around...Adkins seriously underestimated manager..Hope Birmingham dont read twitter

18 minutes ago via web

 

Reply:

@ConnorArmstrong

@DMAC102 I always felt he would be good after seeing him speak on Sky. Fergie turnaround was one of biggest shocks I've experienced!

11 minutes ago via web

 

Reply:

@ConnorArmstrong

 

@DMAC102 As you're open about it now, were #saintsfc ever in for CMS? And is Cortese as bad as journo's / agents make out?

11 minutes ago via web

 

Reply:

@DMAC102

Saints were in before xmas but offer was worst i have ever seen.To embarrassing to put here. Sorry to say. Met Cortese once and was ok.

9 minutes ago via web

 

 

Not much going on this time of the season, so thought some of you could find interest with this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Any chance of updating the thread title, it doesn't make any sense because it doesn't mention "bid".

Perhaps the bid was low to test the water, after all before Xmas no deal could have been completed. Would be interesting to know what was the response, was it "feck off you're having a giraffe" or "thats a trifle lower than our estimation"? Maybe we went back with a better offer after Xmas, or maybe we considered that anything more was not worth the money. Do people really believe what other people tweet? I think the Dutch Athletics chappie had the right idea about twitter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's interesting in that Cortese *talks* about where he wants us to be, but seemingly doesn't want to spend the required wonga.

 

I was castigated by a few when I revealed that our "two insulting bids" for Matt Philips, then of Wycombe WFC, lead to the Wycombe chairman refusing to take calls from our club.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

looks like Matt Philips and CMS both looking for premiership tranfers.

 

would philips have been first choice 11 for money spent?

 

could we have done any better if we had paid £4m or whatever for CMS and would they have sold to rival?

 

This window is more important. Jan window is to get you through the season primarily - we didn't need anymore players unless could get good deal.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We arent a big enough club to simply bend forward and take it up the jacksy with whatever asking price a club dreams up. Chelski we're not, lets wait and see who the management team brings in before complaining about who we didnt. Nick G is right, we wouldnt have done any better with CMS, he couldnt have got us any more promoted than we were....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

really....lambert cost as much as the next 3 big signings that summer combined...!!!!

did we insult martin o'neil with wages too..?

 

Indeed, but the $64,000 question is where are we now that Marcus is no longer with us?

 

We'll have a better idea soon enough because we do need to strengthen, and in my view we need to strenthen considerably to achieve promotion. As I say Cortese talks to the talk, now it's up to the Liebherr family to support his words with hard cash.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by dune 'It's interesting in that Cortese *talks* about where he wants us to be, but seemingly doesn't want to spend the required wonga'.

 

The test comes this summer imo.Can NC & NA attract the right quality to take this club forward.If they don't spend some money I will certainly question where we are heading with how many good sides there are in the ccc.

 

At the moment this team and squad is mid table at best with all the other major clubs strengthening.I hope we will not be resting on our laurels unless I can see us panick buying when things aren't going to plan at the end of August or January.

 

We need 3/4 quality signings to turn us into at least a top 10 side that could possibly make the play offs.For the current season this would equate to a good season imo.

 

Do people really think this current team with no additions will finish above Leeds , Leicester , Burnley , Ipswich , Reading , Notts Forest , Cardiff , Middlesbrough, West Ham and Birmingham.You could also add Hull , Blackpool and Derby to that list.

 

It is an exceptionally tough league next season which makes it more important to strengthen more than maybe what was 1st planned as you have to react to what your main competitors are upto to keep pace.Teams like Ipswich,Leicester and Derby are all busy strengthening.There are at least 12 sides that will be chasing promotion next season believing that they have got a realistic chance.I don't know what is in NC's and NA'S plans but they did say they wanted us to be competitive challenging at the top end of the division. For this to happen money will have to be spent

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by dune 'It's interesting in that Cortese *talks* about where he wants us to be, but seemingly doesn't want to spend the required wonga'.

 

The test comes this summer imo.Can NC & NA attract the right quality to take this club forward.If they don't spend some money I will certainly question where we are heading with how many good sides there are in the ccc.

 

At the moment this team and squad is mid table at best with all the other major clubs strengthening.I hope we will not be resting on our laurels unless I can see us panick buying when things aren't going to plan at the end of August or January.

 

We need 3/4 quality signings to turn us into at least a top 10 side that could possibly make the play offs.For the current season this would equate to a good season imo.

 

Do people really think this current team with no additions will finish above Leeds , Leicester , Burnley , Ipswich , Reading , Notts Forest , Cardiff , Middlesbrough, West Ham and Birmingham.You could also add Hull , Blackpool and Derby to that list.

 

It is an exceptionally tough league next season which makes it more important to strengthen more than maybe what was 1st planned as you have to react to what your main competitors are upto to keep pace.Teams like Ipswich,Leicester and Derby are all busy strengthening.There are at least 12 sides that will be chasing promotion next season believing that they have got a realistic chance.I don't know what is in NC's and NA'S plans but they did say they wanted us to be competitive challenging at the top end of the division. For this to happen money will have to be spent

 

Yep.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by dune 'It's interesting in that Cortese *talks* about where he wants us to be, but seemingly doesn't want to spend the required wonga'.

 

The test comes this summer imo.Can NC & NA attract the right quality to take this club forward.If they don't spend some money I will certainly question where we are heading with how many good sides there are in the ccc.

 

At the moment this team and squad is mid table at best with all the other major clubs strengthening.I hope we will not be resting on our laurels unless I can see us panick buying when things aren't going to plan at the end of August or January.

 

We need 3/4 quality signings to turn us into at least a top 10 side that could possibly make the play offs.For the current season this would equate to a good season imo.

 

Do people really think this current team with no additions will finish above Leeds , Leicester , Burnley , Ipswich , Reading , Notts Forest , Cardiff , Middlesbrough, West Ham and Birmingham.You could also add Hull , Blackpool and Derby to that list.

 

It is an exceptionally tough league next season which makes it more important to strengthen more than maybe what was 1st planned as you have to react to what your main competitors are upto to keep pace.Teams like Ipswich,Leicester and Derby are all busy strengthening.There are at least 12 sides that will be chasing promotion next season believing that they have got a realistic chance.I don't know what is in NC's and NA'S plans but they did say they wanted us to be competitive challenging at the top end of the division. For this to happen money will have to be spent

 

I don't think that's right.

 

I'd say mid table. Full stop.

 

3 or 4 quality signings and we should be a serious play off/promotion contender.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

IMHO the target this season should be mid table/challenging for a playoff spot. IF we have a good preseason, I think we all agree that the current squad can achieve mid-table. in such a tight league a sixth place spot is not far away at christmas when we will strengthen where required.

 

bringing the thread (kind of) back on subject. thanks OP for posting your twitter exchange & starting a decent thread in this long, dull summer. As others have said CMS would have been surplus to requirements last season. But there's nothing wrong with bringing in a good player at the right price & is making a low offer for a player a legal way of "tapping" them up?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

IMHO the target this season should be mid table/challenging for a playoff spot.

 

I bet you the target is much higher than that for next season! ;) :D Why would Cortese set a target of mid table when he wants top half (or better) of the Premier League football asap? Aim low and you will most likely achieve low or lower.

 

The longer it takes to get to the Premier League the harder it will become as you will have to rebuild the squad. May as well use the momentum the club has now and push on ala Norwich.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I bet you the target is much higher than that for next season! ;) :D

 

Sorry I meant realistic target ;)

 

Why would Cortese set a target of mid table when he wants top half (or better) of the Premier League football asap?

 

mid table to challanging for the playoffs is top half. 12th to 6th had a gap last season of 13 pts, it makes sense to see what is required to achieve the best team in the league & it still fits in with the 5 year plan.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why is promotion in 2011/12 not realistic?

 

Promotion (Via the playoffs) is realistic (IMHO) I see no reason why not with the current squad along with a bit of luck.

 

I said top half or better in the Premier League asap, not the Championship.

 

we have to get there first, then we can think about Top Half (in the prem) & Europe. I'd rather sustained growth than spending £4m (quoted above) on CMS when we were in league 1.

 

what offer do you think we should have made?

Edited by westofshannonsaint
Link to comment
Share on other sites

it makes sense to see what is required to achieve the best team in the league & it still fits in with the 5 year plan.

 

From Hypo when he was in a good mood...

 

I have a source at SFC (have posted about him before) and had some lunch with him yesterday where he filled me in on some positive stuff.

 

Cortese has a new five year plan which involves us being top five in the premiership.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If i was a betting man I would wager that the new 5 year plan is from now (top 5 in 2016/17). I know Cortese is ambitious but I am sure he is not without some realism.

 

Paying large sums on players who are surplus to requirements is not rational (he says in a vein attempt to bring the thread back on topic)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I passed on the info but am yet to be convinced by it.

 

Neither am I

 

Top 5 in five years is highly unlikely in my opinion without out spending £300m on transfer fees and loads more on wages

 

Where is the money coming from

 

Since the sad death of Marcus we have spent feck all despite bidding for some players apparently

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Neither am I

 

Top 5 in five years is highly unlikely in my opinion without out spending £300m on transfer fees and loads more on wages

 

Where is the money coming from

 

Since the sad death of Marcus we have spent feck all despite bidding for some players apparently

 

Cue MLG posting exactly what little fees we have spent in his tiring and pedantic manner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cortese was absolutely correct making a low bid, good to see that he isn't going to get mugged off by some of the clowns that run clubs in this country (just take a look at football finances if you want confirmation). For example how much are Hull paying for Jimmy Bullard??

 

Forget about the BS words, it's all about Saints to paying as little as they can and Posh getting as much as they can.

 

That's the dance and Cortese appears to know how to tango.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The worst offer he'd ever seen?

 

£750,000 for a leading player in league 1 is not unreasonable. The money we paid for Rickie Lambert was stellar at the time for the level and the bids here are comparable due to the similar stature of both Bristol Rovers and The Posh.

 

Of course Peterborough have some money behind them now but as a test of resolve, bidding £750 k was absolutely worth doing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cortese was absolutely correct making a low bid, good to see that he isn't going to get mugged off by some of the clowns that run clubs in this country (just take a look at football finances if you want confirmation). For example how much are Hull paying for Jimmy Bullard??

 

Forget about the BS words, it's all about Saints to paying as little as they can and Posh getting as much as they can.

 

That's the dance and Cortese appears to know how to tango.

 

If we wanted CMS and did not get him I think Cortese is the mug

 

To get decent players you have to pay the going rate

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If we wanted CMS and did not get him I think Cortese is the mug

 

To get decent players you have to pay the going rate

 

The point has already been made though that if you have money, or expected to get a lot of it very soon, the Market rate will be different.

 

As it happened we didn't need to sign CMS to be strong enough to go up, therefore it could be argued Cortese handled the situation bang on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

but he would. be right, in whatever manner he posts it

 

Our players in have reduced significantly in terms of Fees paid. We have spent less than we did in our first year and it will be interesting to see whether this continues this year considering that we have a greater need for players this year than last. We spent some money last year but nothing which could not be afforded with our crowds and otter sources of income. Things like bumper contracts to Lallana would be instantly recouped if we were to sell him at any time in the future so even if our financial backing has been reduced, it makes financial sense to give Lallana a decent contract.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...