Saint Garrett Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 He's better than Clasie at the moment IMO. Arguably better than Davis in the DM role also. Must be something that Ronald doesn't rate in him at the moment. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
shurlock Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 (edited) Why do you think that? Koeman has involved Reed with the first team (at training and matchdays) a lot more than most other 20 year old central midfielders in the Premier League. Choice or necessity? Koeman's been a bit sniffy about Reed's distribution. Decent player with room to grow - never let us down when he's been asked to fill in. Loan would be a good idea at a club that's strong on youth development. Edited 18 August, 2015 by shurlock Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Diabolus Ex Machina Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 Why do you think that? Koeman has involved Reed with the first team (at training and matchdays) a lot more than most other 20 year old central midfielders in the Premier League. Not speaking for Batman here but Ronald has always seemed hesitant to put Reed in there from the start on match days even when we are short due to injuries/suspensions. Last year it happened when he played Toby there instead when we were missing Vic or Morgan and at the start of this season he has played Davis back there as well when Reed has been available. The fact that this is not the natural position for either player while it would be for Reed suggests that Koeman thinks he still isn't first team ready. What other clubs do with their 20 year olds is irrelevant to Reeds position. The fact that Romeu has been signed to bolster that position and is seemingly set to go straight ahead of him in the pecking order also supports the theory that he is not highly rated. When Clasie returns from injury he will be fourth choice - 5th if Koeman prefers Davis there so you can see why he might want to go on loan to get game time. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
L1Minus10 Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 Wouldn't have lost 3-0 on Saturday if Reed had played instead of Long, Tadic or Davis. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
shurlock Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 Wouldn't have lost 3-0 on Saturday if Reed had played instead of Long, Tadic or Davis. IIRC, many on here had him down as MOTM when we beat them 3-0 in December and that was without either Morgan or Vic, though we also went 5-3-2/3-5-2 that day. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Badger Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 He's better than Clasie at the moment IMO. Arguably better than Davis in the DM role also. Must be something that Ronald doesn't rate in him at the moment. As Clasie currently has in leg in plaster, I would hope he is. Apart from that, are you really suggesting he is a better option than a fit Clasie, who has played at the WC finals for Holland ? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sadoldgit Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 He's better than Clasie at the moment IMO. Arguably better than Davis in the DM role also. Must be something that Ronald doesn't rate in him at the moment. Mrs SOG is better than Clasie at the moment. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Diabolus Ex Machina Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 Just to highlight why I think Koeman doesn't think Reed is first team ready - Reed started only 5 Prem games for us last season... Everton (Home) - Won 3-0 - Neither Morgan or Victor were playing. Played more of a 5-3-2 formation. Newcastle (Away) - Won 2-1 - None of Morgan, Victor or Toby played. Swansea (Home) - Lost 1-0 - Neither Morgan or Toby played. West Ham (Home) - Drew 0-0 - Neither Morgan or Toby played. Leicester (Away) - Lost 2-0 - Only Morgan was missing. So in total 2 wins, 1 draw, 2 losses, 2 clean sheets. Out of the 3 other players who had been played in the CDM position that season - Victor/Morgan/Toby - at least 2 of them were missing in the games Reed played with the exception of the loss to Leicester when Morgan still wasn't available and Reed would have been the obvious replacement (note: Cork played in no games with Reed last season either which is why he wasn't included in the above stats). Basically we had to be missing at least 2 players (3 if you include Cork) before he was given a chance with one of them potentially being a CB who would have been given the nod ahead of him if available. With Clasie and Romeu now being brought in and Koemans seeming preference for playing Davis (whether out of position as a CDM or changing formation so a second CDM isn't needed) it suggests to me that Reed isn't in line for a lot of game time even though his was a position where we needed depth the most. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Saint Garrett Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 My point was that Clasie doesn't look physically ready yet, although I've only seen very little of him. To play DM you have to be able to put yourself about, I'm not sure Clasie has that in him, although I'm eager to see. It will be interesting to see what happens when everyone is fit in the midfield, especially if Romeu makes a good impact over the next few games. If Davis plays as a CM, then we have to play 3 CM's as he's not good enough defensively for him to play as a DM with Mane/Tadic/JRod as the player in behind the striker. Could we play the below...would it be too defensive? Would Davis be a better "link" than Clasie? -------Romeu---Wanyama-------- -------------Clasie----------------- Tadic-------------------------Mane -------------Pelle------------------- Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Window Cleaner Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 My point was that Clasie doesn't look physically ready yet, although I've only seen very little of him. To play DM you have to be able to put yourself about, I'm not sure Clasie has that in him, although I'm eager to see. It will be interesting to see what happens when everyone is fit in the midfield, especially if Romeu makes a good impact over the next few games. If Davis plays as a CM, then we have to play 3 CM's as he's not good enough defensively for him to play as a DM with Mane/Tadic/JRod as the player in behind the striker. Could we play the below...would it be too defensive? Would Davis be a better "link" than Clasie? -------Romeu---Wanyama-------- -------------Clasie----------------- Tadic-------------------------Mane -------------Pelle------------------- Oh he must be able to "put himself about" number of yellow cards he got last season would tell you that, it might also suggest to you that he doesn't do it particularly well...then again all DMs get yellow cards by the packet. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
VectisSaint Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 Just to highlight why I think Koeman doesn't think Reed is first team ready Perhaps you missed the last bit, the conclusion. You were going to highlight why Ronald does not think Reed is ready. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
simo Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 I'd loan him out with a recall option , playing every week against men is the best way to develop as a player IMO! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Diabolus Ex Machina Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 Perhaps you missed the last bit, the conclusion. You were going to highlight why Ronald does not think Reed is ready. Ok bad choice of wording on my part. I can't speak on Koemans thoughts on Reeds abilities or why he wouldn't think he'd be ready but I think what I put clearly shows that Koeman believes there are a number of players ahead of him at the moment. Think I should also be careful when I say how Koeman 'Rates' him and similar. Just because he hasn't given him much game time doesn't mean he thinks he's a bad player just that he prefers other options currently. He's got plenty of time to improve which is why a loan away if he's not gonna get much time here is a good idea. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jesse Pingman Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 -------Romeu---Wanyama-------- -------------Clasie----------------- Tadic-------------------------Mane -------------Pelle------------------- I've seen people post a line-up like this on here before, which always struck me as weird. Clasie has always been the most defensive of the defensive midfielders at Feyenoord and the dutch national team. He's rarely gotten to the opposition box in his play so far. Don't get me wrong, it might turn out great, he has good distribution and a decent shot, but he's never played there or in a similar role before. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Window Cleaner Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 -------Romeu---Wanyama-------- -------------Clasie----------------- Tadic-------------------------Mane -------------Pelle------------------- I've seen people post a line-up like this on here before, which always struck me as weird. Clasie has always been the most defensive of the defensive midfielders at Feyenoord and the dutch national team. He's rarely gotten to the opposition box in his play so far. Don't get me wrong, it might turn out great, he has good distribution and a decent shot, but he's never played there or in a similar role before. i'd not take suggested line-ups any too seriously if I were you, people just make them up and fit their personal favourites or some costly player in any old where without taking in to consideration his attributes or previous experience. FM is the bane of our age. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
simo Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 -------Romeu---Wanyama-------- -------------Clasie----------------- Tadic-------------------------Mane -------------Pelle------------------- I've seen people post a line-up like this on here before, which always struck me as weird. Clasie has always been the most defensive of the defensive midfielders at Feyenoord and the dutch national team. He's rarely gotten to the opposition box in his play so far. Don't get me wrong, it might turn out great, he has good distribution and a decent shot, but he's never played there or in a similar role before. He has more assists than our other Dmf's that was my reckoning any ways! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Window Cleaner Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 He has more assists than our other Dmf's that was my reckoning any ways! In Dutch football..we all saw just how mediocre their better teams are when we played Feyenoord and Vitesse. I mean Memphis was the bee's bollorks at PSV but he looks a bit average for Utd so far. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
simo Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 In Dutch football..we all saw just how mediocre their better teams are when we played Feyenoord and Vitesse. I mean Memphis was the bee's bollorks at PSV but he looks a bit average for Utd so far. Yet Tadic and Pelle looked mustard first half of last season? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Window Cleaner Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 Yet Tadic and Pelle looked mustard first half of last season? Surprise element I suppose combined with the overiding factor...our DM 2. Not a fanatically big fan of either of them myself but most seem to like them so I must be in the minority. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
verlaine1979 Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 -------Romeu---Wanyama-------- -------------Clasie----------------- Tadic-------------------------Mane -------------Pelle------------------- I've seen people post a line-up like this on here before, which always struck me as weird. Clasie has always been the most defensive of the defensive midfielders at Feyenoord and the dutch national team. He's rarely gotten to the opposition box in his play so far. Don't get me wrong, it might turn out great, he has good distribution and a decent shot, but he's never played there or in a similar role before. I think mostly it's out of blind hope that he'll create more there than the current incumbents in that position. From his cameo last weekend, I'd be surprised if Romeu lost his place alongside VW any time soon - he seems to have a combination of physical presence, concentration and reasonable mid-range passing that make him a bit of a cut-price Schneiderlin. Clasie on the other hand has a reputation for hard work, defensive tenacity & excellent passing that at least, on paper, make him sound like an upgrade on our current first choice 3rd CM, who has the hard work but not the passing quality. It doesn't happen often, but occasionally players do get signed with a different position in mind (e.g. when Man Utd signed Anderson he was being hailed as the new Ronaldinho, but they converted him into a defensive midfielder). Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mr X Posted 18 August, 2015 Share Posted 18 August, 2015 hes been here a whole few weeks now! clasie will be the new Gaston comes with lots of hype & potential but does nothing of note at saints Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SuperSAINT Posted 20 August, 2015 Share Posted 20 August, 2015 http://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2015/08/20/report-derby-county-expected-to-sign-southampton-midfielder-harr/? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Baird of the land Posted 20 August, 2015 Share Posted 20 August, 2015 http://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2015/08/20/report-derby-county-expected-to-sign-southampton-midfielder-harr/? Disappointing if true but its clear Koeman won't give him a proper chance, so its probably best he gets away. Hopefully Clasie gets fit soon as i'm no fan of the mediocre Romeu in that role. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Saint-Armstrong Posted 20 August, 2015 Share Posted 20 August, 2015 http://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2015/08/20/report-derby-county-expected-to-sign-southampton-midfielder-harr/? Stephen Pickering has contacts at Derby County, from what I remember. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CB Fry Posted 20 August, 2015 Share Posted 20 August, 2015 Genuinely would surprise me more than Mane going to Manchester United. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Give it to Ron Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Disappointing if true but its clear Koeman won't give him a proper chance, so its probably best he gets away. Hopefully Clasie gets fit soon as i'm no fan of the mediocre Romeu in that role. Mediocre? He was our best player last night his only crime is he is not Morgan. Written off after 1.5 games brilliant Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CB Fry Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Disappointing if true but its clear Koeman won't give him a proper chance, so its probably best he gets away. Hopefully Clasie gets fit soon as i'm no fan of the mediocre Romeu in that role. Well done on giving him one entire match. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
angelman Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Strange how people see the game differently from each other. Not just slightly, but massively so. I thought, like some others, that Romeu looked good last night. Agree with Give it to Ron, that he was our best player last night - I know that that is subjective, but he looked calm and assured there. I think that he might be a really good signing. His only "crime" might not be that he isn't Morgan, but that he isn't English like Reed. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Totton Sotton Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Everyone slating Romeu.. He was solid last night, didn't put a foot wrong and it's only his first real game after training with the team. He's quite clearly not Morgan or on his level otherwise Chelsea wouldn't of let him go for 5m. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
supersonic Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Joinin Derby on loan. Good move for both sides Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
egg Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Reed is a cracking little player. As neat and tidy as Romeu looked last night I cannot see what he offers that Reed can't. Strange business. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dangermouth Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Reed doesn't know what a forward pass is and kills the speed of the game. Much like a lot of those coming through the acadamy, the obvious difference being the lightweight but now bulkier than last season Hesketh. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
northam soul Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Reed is a cracking little player. As neat and tidy as Romeu looked last night I cannot see what he offers that Reed can't. Strange business. Well for one thing it finally looks like we have a centre mid that can shoot. I also think he had a good game and it wasn't easy for him as all we did was launch it Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
St Chalet Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Everyone slating Romeu.. He was solid last night, didn't put a foot wrong and it's only his first real game after training with the team. He's quite clearly not Morgan or on his level otherwise Chelsea wouldn't of let him go for 5m. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk I'd agree with that. We are not going to fill Morgan's boots anytime soon, but this guy could get close enough. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Saint Garrett Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Romeu looks our best player at the moment. Not sure how anyone can say he's been poor. Good decision to let Reed go out on loan if we have no interest in playing him - FWIW I think he can do a decent job for us this season, but it will be good for him to get some games. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
VectisSaint Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Disappointing if true but its clear Koeman won't give him a proper chance, so its probably best he gets away. Hopefully Clasie gets fit soon as i'm no fan of the mediocre Romeu in that role. Don't think you really understand do you. Romeu looks very good (better than expected when replacing a top class player who has left), and he and Clasie will both (eventually) be in the team. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
VectisSaint Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Strange how people see the game differently from each other. Not just slightly, but massively so. I thought, like some others, that Romeu looked good last night. Agree with Give it to Ron, that he was our best player last night - I know that that is subjective, but he looked calm and assured there. I think that he might be a really good signing. His only "crime" might not be that he isn't Morgan, but that he isn't English like Reed. Romeu was probably our best player last night. He also changed things massively on Saturday when he came on. Not bad for someone straight in the team. He will probably never completely replace Morgan, people need to understand that Morgan is really a world class player, there are not many of his standard around so how can you replace, but Romeu is not too shabby. Only down side is that he has picked up 2 yellows already, though to be fair neither were warranted. Picking up a yellow early in a game does have a detrimental effect, having to play with a bit of caution subsequently. Will be good to see him play without a card hanging over his head. That said Morgan was not exactly unfamiliar with cards of various colours. It goes with the territory. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Batman Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 I thought Romeu was pretty good. Looks tough, decent in the air and likely to have a pop from edge of the area Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Katalinic Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Well done on giving him one entire match. Quite, and he was far from mediocre. Has been our best player in the 1.5 games he has played. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sadoldgit Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Romeu was probably our best player last night. He also changed things massively on Saturday when he came on. Not bad for someone straight in the team. He will probably never completely replace Morgan, people need to understand that Morgan is really a world class player, there are not many of his standard around so how can you replace, but Romeu is not too shabby. Only down side is that he has picked up 2 yellows already, though to be fair neither were warranted. Picking up a yellow early in a game does have a detrimental effect, having to play with a bit of caution subsequently. Will be good to see him play without a card hanging over his head. That said Morgan was not exactly unfamiliar with cards of various colours. It goes with the territory. As good as Morgan was for us, I think World Class is pushing it a bit. He is still not a shoe-in with the French side. Players that good, Zidane for example, are the first name on the team sheet. Maybe he will eventually become World Class but at his age I think it is unlikely. Quality player clearly though. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DuncanRG Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 http://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2015/08/20/report-derby-county-expected-to-sign-southampton-midfielder-harr/? A real shame the academy boys are being farmed out again. Doesn't seem as important to Koeman as it did previous managers. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Twiggy Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Romeu likes a pop from distance aswell which I'm a fan of. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
S-Clarke Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 A real shame the academy boys are being farmed out again. Doesn't seem as important to Koeman as it did previous managers. Or another way of looking at it is the quality isn't the same as it was (chambers/shaw). And we've moved up a notch. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wrensup Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 As good as Morgan was for us, I think World Class is pushing it a bit. He is still not a shoe-in with the French side. Players that good, Zidane for example, are the first name on the team sheet. Maybe he will eventually become World Class but at his age I think it is unlikely. Quality player clearly though. You say that but judging by what theit manager says about playing for big clubs, it's that fact that he 'isnt the first name on the team sheet' rather than his ability Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
egg Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Well for one thing it finally looks like we have a centre mid that can shoot. I also think he had a good game and it wasn't easy for him as all we did was launch it He had a good first half but faded second. Whilst he likes a pop from a range where he's unlikely to score , he's ill disciplined. His yellow was harsh but the tackle didn't need to be made. He pushed his luck after that and was very lucky to stay on. The ref played an advantage rather than blowing up in the second half when he hauled the man down. Had the ref blown it was a certain second yellow. Don't get me wrong, he looks decent but I'm not persuaded that he offers more than Reed could . Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Give it to Ron Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 He had a good first half but faded second. Whilst he likes a pop from a range where he's unlikely to score , he's ill disciplined. His yellow was harsh but the tackle didn't need to be made. He pushed his luck after that and was very lucky to stay on. The ref played an advantage rather than blowing up in the second half when he hauled the man down. Had the ref blown it was a certain second yellow. Don't get me wrong, he looks decent but I'm not persuaded that he offers more than Reed could . Reed isn't ill disciplined? You missed the u21 final then! The World Class Morgan wasn't exactly squeaky clean was he. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
VectisSaint Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 As good as Morgan was for us, I think World Class is pushing it a bit. He is still not a shoe-in with the French side. Players that good, Zidane for example, are the first name on the team sheet. Maybe he will eventually become World Class but at his age I think it is unlikely. Quality player clearly though. He's at ManU now, he will be. You underestimate the man. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sadoldgit Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 You say that but judging by what theit manager says about playing for big clubs, it's that fact that he 'isnt the first name on the team sheet' rather than his ability World Class is players like Ronaldo, Messi, Zidane etc. Morgan doesn't sit in with that type of player yet. Being at Manchester United might help his cause but you can hardly be World Class if you are not a regular for your national team. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wrensup Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 World Class is players like Ronaldo, Messi, Zidane etc. Morgan doesn't sit in with that type of player yet. Being at Manchester United might help his cause but you can hardly be World Class if you are not a regular for your national team. Essentially there you said only two players of this generation are world class and thats it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Doctoroncall Posted 21 August, 2015 Share Posted 21 August, 2015 Reed is a cracking little player. As neat and tidy as Romeu looked last night I cannot see what he offers that Reed can't. Strange business. He'll need plenty of game time under his belt as I think he'll play a lot more next season when the next batch of Saint leavers go (i.e Wanyama). It will be interesting to see where Clasie will play as a few have put him in front of a DM pairing... will he be the transition player with his accurate passing turning defence into attack? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now