New Manager Debate

[Sheaf Saint]

32 minutes ago, Doctoroncall said:

May the odds be ever in your favour. 

[Toadhall Saint]

38 minutes ago, Willo of Whiteley said:

I doubt Will still interviewed. He’s been back in Belgium with family pretty since his sacking.

Pinch of salt that.

And you know that how?

[Gloucester Saint]

18 minutes ago, skintsaint said:

For the women's team nude 2026 charity calendar photo shoot?

Time for @Pilchards  tree and some granular binoculars 

[Sheaf Saint]

37 minutes ago, Willo of Whiteley said:

I doubt Will still interviewed. He’s been back in Belgium with family pretty since his sacking.

Pinch of salt that.

OK even ignoring the point that has been raised multiple times already about conducting interviews remotely, didn't he say that he wanted to come back to the UK to support his partner through serious illness?

From a Saints perspective, it would be great if Norwich did appoint him now. Not only would it massively reduce our liability to pay up his contract, we haven't played them yet home or away (in the league anyway) so it would be a guaranteed 6 points for us because all we would have to do is put numbers in midfield.

[skintsaint]

3 minutes ago, Sheaf Saint said:

From a Saints perspective, it would be great if Norwich did appoint him now. Not only would it massively reduce our liability to pay up his contract, we haven't played them yet home or away (in the league anyway) so it would be a guaranteed 6 points for us because all we would have to do is put numbers in midfield.

Be interesting in his next gig, whether he plays 3 at the back.

[MindtheGab]

57 minutes ago, Willo of Whiteley said:

I doubt Will still interviewed. He’s been back in Belgium with family pretty since his sacking.

Pinch of salt that.

He's had interest from Championship and Ligue 1 so not beyond the realms that he has had an interview at Norwich.

Would be fascinated to see how he gets on without a squad of Russell Martin fanboys

[Wade Garrett]

8 minutes ago, MindtheGab said:

He's had interest from Championship and Ligue 1 so not beyond the realms that he has had an interview at Norwich.

Would be fascinated to see how he gets on without a squad of Russell Martin fanboys

Shit, I expect.

[Dusic]

13 hours ago, MB said:

Not convinced it’s Ekhart, one of the interviews went very well today 

I admire the continued commitment to the ITK persona. Keep hacking into those interviews to bring us the latest!

[AlexLaw76]

12 minutes ago, MindtheGab said:

He's had interest from Championship and Ligue 1 so not beyond the realms that he has had an interview at Norwich.

Would be fascinated to see how he gets on without a squad of Russell Martin fanboys

He was pretty shit when he had the majority of the team who were nothing to do with RM.

[Saint86]

2 hours ago, vectraman said:

Looking at the realistic options on that list, I’m guessing Carrick is the most obvious? Assuming SR don’t go full SR and appoint Tonda…..

My working assumptions are that, A.) we will continue with Tonda in an interim role - until such time that he's done well enough to justify keeping the job, or B.) someone genuinely good appears on the horizon and is interested... or C.) we stick with Tonda but he's doing really badly, and that leads to earthquakes behind the scenes leading us to move for someone they don't particularly fancy.

So in essence, unless things change - my expectation is that its going to be Tonda.

Also, i suspect the main reason Still was sacked when he was, was because of fan discontent and increasing anger towards the board - they've done this since Ralph - once the fans are on their case they quickly move to sack the manager. Now we've won a couple of games, fans aren't venting at the board in the stadium, so the pressure has abated.

Edited yesterday at 13:00 by Saint86

[Dusic]

Just now, Saint86 said:

My working assumption are that A.) we will continue with Tonda in an interim role - until such time that he's done well enough to justify keeping the job, or B.) someone genuinely good appears on the horizon and is interested...,

That or C.) we stick with Tonda but he's doing really badly, and that leads to earthquakes behind the scenes leading us to move for someone they don't particularly fancy.

So in essence, unless things change - my expectation is that its going to be Tonda.

So far most available evidence suggests this to be the case.

[saintant]

1 hour ago, CamSaint said:

How many interviews would Spors require for the 'preferred candidate(s)'? Martin said that he had numerous interviews before being appointed at Rangers, and Ekhart said that he had 4 (I think) interviews at Saints before getting the U-21 job. I know both of those situations were in the close season, but I'd imagine that Spors & the Board would want to interview those short listed more than once........ 

Sounds like a very thorough process. You'd think SR would manage to get something right once in a while.

[tdmickey3]

1 minute ago, Saint86 said:

My working assumptions are that, A.) we will continue with Tonda in an interim role - until such time that he's done well enough to justify keeping the job, or B.) someone genuinely good appears on the horizon and is interested... or C.) we stick with Tonda but he's doing really badly, and that leads to earthquakes behind the scenes leading us to move for someone they don't particularly fancy.

So in essence, unless things change - my expectation is that its going to be Tonda.

It will be my disappointment but not a real surprise given the seemingly lack of understanding of football at SR

[M271]

I would have thought if they we sticking with Tonda it would have been announced by now.

[skintsaint]

6 minutes ago, M271 said:

I would have thought if they we sticking with Tonda it would have been announced by now.

Still doing the photoshoot

[Tamesaint]

14 hours ago, MB said:

Not convinced it’s Ekhart, one of the interviews went very well today 

Was that the German or the ex PL player that you have mentioned before? Or is there someone else? 

[Saint Scott]

11 hours ago, goodymatt said:

 

Fulham would be mad to get rid of Silva.

They were the very definition of yoyo team in the last decade, but since he took over from Parker he lead them to The Championship title, 10th, 11th and 13th place finishes.

If they want Rodgers then go for it, we'll take Silva

[AlexLaw76]

3 minutes ago, Saint Scott said:

Fulham would be mad to get rid of Silva.

They were the very definition of yoyo team in the last decade, but since he took over from Parker he lead them to The Championship title, 10th, 11th and 13th place finishes.

If they want Rodgers then go for it, we'll take Silva

I think it is more of a case of Silva getting rid of Fulham

[Jack]

33 minutes ago, Saint86 said:

My working assumptions are that, A.) we will continue with Tonda in an interim role - until such time that he's done well enough to justify keeping the job, or B.) someone genuinely good appears on the horizon and is interested... or C.) we stick with Tonda but he's doing really badly, and that leads to earthquakes behind the scenes leading us to move for someone they don't particularly fancy.

So in essence, unless things change - my expectation is that its going to be Tonda.

Also, i suspect the main reason Still was sacked when he was, was because of fan discontent and increasing anger towards the board - they've done this since Ralph - once the fans are on their case they quickly move to sack the manager. Now we've won a couple of games, fans aren't venting at the board in the stadium, so the pressure has abated.

You’d hope they’d read the room better than that, but probably not. They’re on thin ice with the fans. Another bad performance or 2, without fortunate wins to put a gloss on it, the fans will be after the board again. The majority expect them to be taking a new manager search very seriously after what they’ve served up in recent times. Appointing an unknown kid who’s never managed at senior level before would be an extremely stupid move and clearly not what this club needs in a time of crisis. 

[CSA96]

It's a bit of both I think. Silva has been touting himself about for all sorts (which he has a rep for already), and so has his agent, but that Fulham contract is difficult for another club to get him out of. Was pretty keen on going to Saudi by all accounts and was the top target for the Forest job too

[Saint Scott]

5 minutes ago, AlexLaw76 said:

I think it is more of a case of Silva getting rid of Fulham

The linked article suggests Fulham are looking to get rid of him

[Willo of Whiteley]

Fulham want rid of him and he wants to go, yet no one wants to make the move to do so because it would require a large payout 😅

Fascinated by these interviews that have been happening, intrigued to know whose interview went well. Gonna be awkward if it was Russell Martin though. 👀🤣

[trousers]

39 minutes ago, skintsaint said:

Still doing the photoshoot

Bit of a come down from first team manager to club photographer.

[Dr Who?]

Just now, trousers said:

Bit of a come down from first team manager to club photographer.

Don’t know 🤔 

[Sevvy]

1 hour ago, Gloucester Saint said:

 

For the women's team nude 2026 charity calendar photo shoot?

 

Time for @Pilchards  tree and some granular binoculars 

 

Apparently Pilchards fell out of such tree, couldn't hold on one hand with the binoculars and one hand on his todger,

 

Edited yesterday at 14:19 by Sevvy

[Miltonaggro]

3 hours ago, Turkish said:

Do we need to get Stu Romsey Saints to take him on a tour of Romsey? Maybe they could meet up for "chat"

When i last spoke PV he thought that Romsey was Pompey, which he fucking hates. Lost in translation, but I didn’t like to say anything, c’est la vie! 

[Mr Saints]

Trollope going to Wolves with Rob Edwards. More reason to hope we have a manager coming in with his own staff.... hopefully.

[tdmickey3]

2 minutes ago, Mr Saints said:

Trollope going to Wolves with Rob Edwards. More reason to hope we have a manager coming in with his own staff.... hopefully.

Can he take nivea boy too... no use to us

[sotonjoe]

15 minutes ago, Mr Saints said:

Trollope going to Wolves with Rob Edwards. More reason to hope we have a manager coming in with his own staff.... hopefully.

I can see the headlines now ...

 

SAINTS LOAD OFF OLD TROLLOPE

[madge]

Hope it’s Ralph… 

[DT]

Tick tock.

Rasmus rewriting his Ted Talk about how he revolutionised everything.

Please be some good, progressive, sensible  and not trendy bollocks news around the corner. Like a manager with experience. That old thing.

[Toussaint]

10 minutes ago, madge said:

Hope it’s Ralph… 

Hope its not

[Willo of Whiteley]

4 minutes ago, DT said:

Tick tock.

Rasmus rewriting his Ted Talk about how he revolutionised everything.

Please be some good, progressive, sensible  and not trendy bollocks news around the corner. Like a manager with experience. That old thing.

Rasmus: Vol II

“If you thought everything was worth breaking it when it was fine; consider absolutely annotating, pissing it up the wall, and burying every piece of good stuff that had happened in previous years. It’s Rasmus time baby”

[Hawkswood]

How's comes so many of the regular posters haven't vote for who they'd like to see as new manager  ?? 🤔  Somethings afoot....

Also, and separately, I noticed that all the other clubs have - from what I can see - publicly stated who they are linked with, even after their search started after ours. SR really do treat the Saints fans with zero respect. Again, unless Ive missed something but thats how it feels.

[OldNick]

We dont need to appoint Eckhart, we just leave him as he is until he either messes up or becomes the best thing since sliced bread.

This gives the club a bit of time. I get that we cnt lose more games in the next 3 but whoever we appoint may not fire us up straight away. 

[EBS1980]

Trollope going to wolves either works out perfectly and allows the new manager to bring his own staff in easier or we will have an interim coach to go with the interim manager 

[Patrick Bateman]

1 minute ago, EBS1980 said:

Trollope going to wolves either works out perfectly and allows the new manager to bring his own staff in easier or we will have an interim coach to go with the interim manager 

Wonder if Wolves had to pay compensation for him then? Win win. 

[skintsaint]

6 minutes ago, Patrick Bateman said:

Wonder if Wolves had to pay compensation for him then? Win win. 

SR Staff trading profit win.

[EBS1980]

6 minutes ago, Patrick Bateman said:

Wonder if Wolves had to pay compensation for him then? Win win. 

Saves us paying compo to sack him if not needed by new manager. 

[Fabrice29]

54 minutes ago, Hawkswood said:

 

Also, and separately, I noticed that all the other clubs have - from what I can see - publicly stated who they are linked with, even after their search started after ours. 

What does this entail? 

[S-Clarke]

17 minutes ago, Patrick Bateman said:

Wonder if Wolves had to pay compensation for him then? Win win. 

Probably, works out quite well timing wise.

So, we now have a GK Coach, performance coach (fitness and analysis?), assistant and first team coach roles vacant. Any new manager can now build his own team around him, as we have the space. The only hanger on would be Lallana at this point.

So even less reason, in my eyes, that they'd go for Eckert with such little experience around the place in the coaching setup.

But talk about failing upwards. Trollope and Edwards were both a part in the relegation of Luton to L1, yet they've jumped back up to the prem. 

Edited yesterday at 16:40 by S-Clarke

[Wurzel]

7 minutes ago, S-Clarke said:

Probably, works out quite well timing wise.

So, we now have a GK Coach, performance coach (fitness and analysis?), assistant and first team coach roles vacant. Any new manager can now build his own team around him, as we have the space. The only hanger on would be Lallana at this point.

So even less reason, in my eyes, that they'd go for Eckert with such little experience around the place in the coaching setup.

But talk about failing upwards. Trollope and Edwards were both a part in the relegation of Luton to L1, yet they've jumped back up to the prem. 

Spors & Viera are getting the band back together🤞

"AI Overview

Patrick Vieira's backroom staff at Genoa included 

assistant manager Kristian Wilson and goalkeeping coaches Stefano Raggio Garibaldi and Alessio Scarpi, but they are no longer with the club. Genoa replaced the entire coaching staff with interim coaches Roberto Murgita and Domenico Criscito following Vieira's departure in November 2025"

[Nolan]

Rumour I was told today was that there was a shortlist of three non British candidates. 

But that there would be no movement as the risk of a backlash if the new appointee lost after Eckert had won two, was too great.

Would only be movement if Eckert dropped points.

[Stripey McStripe Shirt]

18 hours ago, Stripey McStripe Shirt said:

Photoshoot booked in for 10am tomorrow 👀🤐

The doc is in the building.

[Suhari]

2 minutes ago, Stripey McStripe Shirt said:

The doc is in the building.

And he's using the nunchuks.

[saintant]

4 hours ago, Nolan said:

Rumour I was told today was that there was a shortlist of three non British candidates. 

But that there would be no movement as the risk of a backlash if the new appointee lost after Eckert had won two, was too great.

Would only be movement if Eckert dropped points.

If true it gets madder! Shows they are not that confident in any of the three if they think there'd be a backlash after a loss away to Charlton which many expect to happen anyway regardless of who is in charge. Time SR grew a pair.

Edited yesterday at 21:03 by saintant

[Wade Garrett]

20 minutes ago, Nolan said:

Rumour I was told today was that there was a shortlist of three non British candidates. 

But that there would be no movement as the risk of a backlash if the new appointee lost after Eckert had won two, was too great.

Would only be movement if Eckert dropped points.

If true, that just shows how out of touch SR are with the fanbase.

It's not like there's a mad clamour to give Eckert the job.

Personally, I don't believe that one.

[Chez]

 

 

1 hour ago, Hawkswood said:

Also, and separately, I noticed that all the other clubs have - from what I can see - publicly stated who they are linked with, even after their search started after ours. SR really do treat the Saints fans with zero respect. Again, unless Ive missed something but thats how it feels.

I just visited the Swansea City website and unsurprisingly there is absolutely nothing on there about who they have been linked with. Same with Norwich and Boro. Have these three clubs posted something on their social media feeds? If not, then I don't have a clue what you are on about.

[hypochondriac]

3 minutes ago, Chez said:

 

 

I just visited the Swansea City website and unsurprisingly there is absolutely nothing on there about who they have been linked with. Same with Norwich and Boro. Have these three clubs posted something on their social media feeds? If not, then I don't have a clue what you are on about.

I don't see why it matters anyway. No one is choosing Norwich or Swansea over us. Boro maybe.

[Chez]

Interesting article about Celtic being linked to Columbus Crew manager Wilfried Nancy. https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/cdegj67p1z2o 

I wonder if he was on our radar and would a championship side like us be attractive to him?